RX8 VS Mazdaspeed 3
#6
Rotary addict
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Virginia
Posts: 65
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I wouldn't be so quick to say the Speed3 is faster even in a straight line. I have a buddy with the Speed3 and we've run several times. I don't have any problem pulling him. Of course, I don't mind dumping the clutch at around 6k and I'm not quite stock anymore either (although I am still NA).
#7
always filling [the c]up
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Alice, Texas
Posts: 1,267
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is this another one of those periods of time when a bunch of "RX8 vs _____" threads start popping up again?
I, myself, have driven an ms3 - they are quick. Handling sucks, braking sucks, and I overrevved it in second because it didn't beeeeeeeep
Just depends on the driver, but ANYBODY can be fast in a straight.
I, myself, have driven an ms3 - they are quick. Handling sucks, braking sucks, and I overrevved it in second because it didn't beeeeeeeep
Just depends on the driver, but ANYBODY can be fast in a straight.
#8
Screw gas mileage
#9
Registered
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: NE Wisconsin
Posts: 160
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Finally, I've been waiting for this one to show up... LOL And why is this in competition forum again?
Neither of them drive themselves, so the one with faster driver is faster.
Neither of them drive themselves, so the one with faster driver is faster.
#10
1935 lbs. FTW!
I wouldn't be so quick to say the Speed3 is faster even in a straight line. I have a buddy with the Speed3 and we've run several times. I don't have any problem pulling him. Of course, I don't mind dumping the clutch at around 6k and I'm not quite stock anymore either (although I am still NA).
#11
Rotary addict
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Virginia
Posts: 65
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Unless you want to turn. If you've actually driven both of these cars at the track, perhaps you're the one that needs driving lessons. Please don't quote me C&D or R&T numbers as a response to this. We've swapped and he can beat me when he's in the 8 and I'm driving his 3. Some of us live in the real world not on a magazine page. I made a point of saying that I wasn't quite stock anymore, but even without spray, if you eliminate wheel spin using a few simple cheap suspension mods and do the few power train mods that improve NA performance you'll hit low 14's no problem. Using spray it's not even a race any longer and god help him if he needs to brake or turn at speed. That's actually the biggest problem with adding those bolt ons to the Speed3. It doesn't handle all that great with the power it has. You're thinking is correct when you say that he can get a decent amount of power out of his bolt ons, but he'd better mod the suspension heavily in order to control it.
#12
I almost bought a MS3 before I found my 2005 RX8......It's alot faster then the RX8 just cruising around town and in a straight line. Once things get serious it's easy to overwhelm the MS3. As far as I'm concerned they're not in the same league......Think about what you really want and then make your decision.
#16
Watch your six
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: alabama
Posts: 222
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
alright..i've owned both.. so i'll chime in
the rx-8 will beat the 3 in only 2 catagories.. in extreme twisties and in looks.. other than that..it's the 3. and that's stock.. add mods...and there's no comparison. it'd be nice if the 8 would take to mods like the 3 does/will but it doesn't.
have faith though..i hear the new rx-7 is supposed to come out in like 2010 or something.. if that doesn't beat the 3..then i don't know what mazda is doin anymore.
the rx-8 will beat the 3 in only 2 catagories.. in extreme twisties and in looks.. other than that..it's the 3. and that's stock.. add mods...and there's no comparison. it'd be nice if the 8 would take to mods like the 3 does/will but it doesn't.
have faith though..i hear the new rx-7 is supposed to come out in like 2010 or something.. if that doesn't beat the 3..then i don't know what mazda is doin anymore.
#17
I've had an MS3 try to race (or he thought I was racing him, I was in 6th cruising and never floored it or shifted cause the girlfriend was with me sleep and sick) and he pulled off pretty strong (little punk even flashed his lights). But no where as strong as say 350Z or EVO would have. I think what people are feeling when they get into the MS3 is the torque. The MS3 pulls hard until 6K rpms then you may as well shift, as reported in many reviews of it (I'll test drive one soon enough). It also weighs quite a bit too. Don't get me wrong, it's fast, but not THAT fast. I agree with Flynbri. It's probably overrated.
But I will test drive it soon to seen what all the fuss is about for myself. I'm pretty picky about drivers feel in a car. I test drove the EVO and the 8 back to back and still chose the 8.
But I will test drive it soon to seen what all the fuss is about for myself. I'm pretty picky about drivers feel in a car. I test drove the EVO and the 8 back to back and still chose the 8.
#19
Registered
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: NE Wisconsin
Posts: 160
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't think there's much question that the 8 is faster once the road start to curve, it's the power that gets everybody talking.
How about this: if you want hot single lady, the 8 will get you there faster; if you want hot single mom, get the 3.
How about this: if you want hot single lady, the 8 will get you there faster; if you want hot single mom, get the 3.
#20
alright..i've owned both.. so i'll chime in
the rx-8 will beat the 3 in only 2 catagories.. in extreme twisties and in looks.. other than that..it's the 3. and that's stock.. add mods...and there's no comparison. it'd be nice if the 8 would take to mods like the 3 does/will but it doesn't.
have faith though..i hear the new rx-7 is supposed to come out in like 2010 or something.. if that doesn't beat the 3..then i don't know what mazda is doin anymore.
the rx-8 will beat the 3 in only 2 catagories.. in extreme twisties and in looks.. other than that..it's the 3. and that's stock.. add mods...and there's no comparison. it'd be nice if the 8 would take to mods like the 3 does/will but it doesn't.
have faith though..i hear the new rx-7 is supposed to come out in like 2010 or something.. if that doesn't beat the 3..then i don't know what mazda is doin anymore.
I don't know what people think they are talking about.
There are only 2 categories that the MS3 will out do an RX-8. 0-60 and gas mileage. Even in the 0-60, it's really close and would depend on the driver. Depending on the driver and the RPM he is launching at, the 0-60 can go to the RX-8.
Brakes, turns, handling, etc... go to the RX-8.
Also, there are mods for the RX-8. Has nobody paid attention to the Pettit SC, Greddy Turbo, Mazsport Turbo (versions of the kit can put down 400 HP), etc...??? There are NA mods for the RX-8 like AP pulley, flywheel, exhaust, ram air duct, etc... Now you may question what the gains are for the mods on each car, but don't think the RX-8 can't get improvement from its mods.
Furthermore, the RX-8 can handle the mods in terms of handling of the car. The MS3 is still a box, that with too much power you may "lose control" in the wrong situation.
Lastly, when it comes to looks of the car, there is no comparison. The RX-8 wins hands down.
#21
Thread Pirate, Ahhrrrrr
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Long Island, NY
Posts: 784
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#22
Apexing at Oak Tree
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: The Blue, Educated State in the North
Posts: 717
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I wouldn't be so quick to say the Speed3 is faster even in a straight line. I have a buddy with the Speed3 and we've run several times. I don't have any problem pulling him. Of course, I don't mind dumping the clutch at around 6k and I'm not quite stock anymore either (although I am still NA).
I currently own both cars so I may be the best qualified to answer this. There is no way in hell a stock RX-8 will walk a stock MS3, if you think so, you are drunk. In fact, I don't think there is anyway any NA RX-8 will walk a Speed3. An RX-8 with a turbo kit running 10+ psi might have a chance. There is a guy on another forum who is running over 300 fwhp and well over 300 fw torque with about $2000 in mods ( Protege Garage TMIC, MS CAI, XEDE, and CP-E exhaust). I don't car how you spend $2000 on an RX-8, you won't get there. The Speed3 is also no slouch in handling either, but won't touch the RX-8 in this category. Stock vs. Stock I think the Speed3 will run away on the track. Now an RX-8 with a turbo kit vs. stock MS3, if the track doesn't have long straights, I take the RX-8. IMHO, the only way an RX-8 will walk a Speed3 (in a straight line) is with a Mazsport Turbo Kit. A properly tuned GReddy kit will take a Speed3 on a twisty track (NHIS, Pacific Raceways).
Now all that being said, which is more fun to drive? Hands down the RX-8. The Speed3 is FWD, and we all know the limitations there. At the track, the Speed3 would just be drag racing between corners, and thats not much fun (if you want to do that, go get a Mustang GT). The RX-8's gearbox is better, handling is better, more sexy, etc etc. I will not be tracking my Speed3 because the 8 is too much fun.
#23
I Heart 2nd Gear Racing
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Tampa, FL
Posts: 162
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From a different thread ...
I know. It's just a magazine comparison, but if it's faster round this track than a S2000, it's probably faster round this track than a RX8. If not faster, then at least comparable.
I can tell you the 8 would smoke it in autocross.
Rankings (and biggest putdowns);
10. Civic Si (too soft)
9. Z06 (very nervous feeling)
8. MS3 (lotsa torque steer, but faster lap than S2000!)
7. S2000 (lack of chassis rigidity)
6. 335i (heavy and lazy, but best real world compromise)
5. Mini Cooper S JCW GP (exaggerated traits)
4. Evo (drifts and wears tires, but "idiot proof")
3. Exige S (rough ride, a bit twitchy)
2. Cayman S (less rigid than the 911)
1. 911 GT3..."perfect"
10. Civic Si (too soft)
9. Z06 (very nervous feeling)
8. MS3 (lotsa torque steer, but faster lap than S2000!)
7. S2000 (lack of chassis rigidity)
6. 335i (heavy and lazy, but best real world compromise)
5. Mini Cooper S JCW GP (exaggerated traits)
4. Evo (drifts and wears tires, but "idiot proof")
3. Exige S (rough ride, a bit twitchy)
2. Cayman S (less rigid than the 911)
1. 911 GT3..."perfect"
I can tell you the 8 would smoke it in autocross.
#25
Registered User
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Perth, Western Australia
Posts: 65
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
^ Well I think that about settles it.
I test drove a MS3 and liked it but I really hate FWD understeer. If the car was RWD or AWD it'd be a great little car.
I test drove a MS3 and liked it but I really hate FWD understeer. If the car was RWD or AWD it'd be a great little car.