Finally a plug and play ECU!!!
#77
Can we get an extension harness to put this AND the stock ECU someplace less hostile? Our company engineer laughed and shook his head when I showed him where the ECU on the '8 is.. its just a damn stupid place for it. Unless there would be too much signal loss from extending the cables, I'd much rather throw this whole 9 yards under a seat or into my trunk.
Electronics + heat = bad.
Over 300hp on stock injectors? That's one thing I have trouble swallowing.. aren't these small injectors? I would think that 300whp on stock injectors would be pushing them close to static, which is not a good thing at all.
Electronics + heat = bad.
Over 300hp on stock injectors? That's one thing I have trouble swallowing.. aren't these small injectors? I would think that 300whp on stock injectors would be pushing them close to static, which is not a good thing at all.
#78
Originally Posted by brillo
it can control fuel and spark in all conditions, open and closed loop.
Does it then give you full authority on where you want to run open or closed loop? Is there an open/closed loop table?
Say, if I want your system to run in closed loop fuelling mode, using the OEM wide band lambda sensor, at 4500 rpm, 0.65 load, and at a lambda of 1.15, can I do it?
Also, you did not answer the question regarding knock control. Are you loosing that feature with your system?
#80
Originally Posted by RXhusker
Well, being my typical early adopter self -- I just ordered one.
Scott said that the first batch should be shipped by the end of the month. Spent 30 minutes on the phone with Mazsport -- seems like they really have their act together (cough -- unlike SSR - cough cough). He mentioned there will be a number of planned stages for upgrades to the turbo kit. After this ECU the next will be a custom machining of the GReddy turbo to add about 20% capacity so that greater boost can be taken to the higher RPM range -- Scott said this should take us well over 300whp with the stock injectors, etc. :D He also talked about an upgrade for the intake to get lower intake temps.
Scott said that the first batch should be shipped by the end of the month. Spent 30 minutes on the phone with Mazsport -- seems like they really have their act together (cough -- unlike SSR - cough cough). He mentioned there will be a number of planned stages for upgrades to the turbo kit. After this ECU the next will be a custom machining of the GReddy turbo to add about 20% capacity so that greater boost can be taken to the higher RPM range -- Scott said this should take us well over 300whp with the stock injectors, etc. :D He also talked about an upgrade for the intake to get lower intake temps.
I want this unit with Hymee's supercharge...then I'll be content :D
#81
I think Scott said that they are going to post a Q&A section in their vendor site tomorrow so all these questions may be addressed.
He was talking to me about all the control features -- but to be honest with you guys -- it was way over my head. I am sure he said that we still have the anti-knock sensors/features intact, etc. He indicated that just over 300 was limit of duty cycle safety margin for the stock injectors. I think he mentioned plans for like 5 stages of mods with (please don't quote me on this...) like 450+ whp potential with the modified GReddy kit (injectors, turbo mods, etc.) based on the computer analysis they have done. I think he has a good understanding that the majority of us would like smooth reliable 300whp power from our GReddy kits without major mods (fuel, battery placement, etc.) and a few would like very high HP racing applications.
I would suggest giving them a call -- I was impressed with how professional, knowledgeable and articulate he appears to be. I remember calling another vendor (they shall remain nameless -- but they have been promising to put out dyno numbers on their turbo with a shop in San Diego) and being less than impressed with the answers I received.
He was talking to me about all the control features -- but to be honest with you guys -- it was way over my head. I am sure he said that we still have the anti-knock sensors/features intact, etc. He indicated that just over 300 was limit of duty cycle safety margin for the stock injectors. I think he mentioned plans for like 5 stages of mods with (please don't quote me on this...) like 450+ whp potential with the modified GReddy kit (injectors, turbo mods, etc.) based on the computer analysis they have done. I think he has a good understanding that the majority of us would like smooth reliable 300whp power from our GReddy kits without major mods (fuel, battery placement, etc.) and a few would like very high HP racing applications.
I would suggest giving them a call -- I was impressed with how professional, knowledgeable and articulate he appears to be. I remember calling another vendor (they shall remain nameless -- but they have been promising to put out dyno numbers on their turbo with a shop in San Diego) and being less than impressed with the answers I received.
#82
Originally Posted by Rasputin
I think you did not undertsand what I meant.
Does it then give you full authority on where you want to run open or closed loop? Is there an open/closed loop table?
Say, if I want your system to run in closed loop fuelling mode, using the OEM wide band lambda sensor, at 4500 rpm, 0.65 load, and at a lambda of 1.15, can I do it?
Also, you did not answer the question regarding knock control. Are you loosing that feature with your system?
Does it then give you full authority on where you want to run open or closed loop? Is there an open/closed loop table?
Say, if I want your system to run in closed loop fuelling mode, using the OEM wide band lambda sensor, at 4500 rpm, 0.65 load, and at a lambda of 1.15, can I do it?
Also, you did not answer the question regarding knock control. Are you loosing that feature with your system?
As far as knock control goes, this too would be another driect question for Mazsport. brillo and myself are working on our own project but unlike this one ours isn't going into production. What ours does and what theirs does is probably similar but there will always be some differences. The stock knock sensor is undoubtedly still hooked up to the stock ecu but since the stock ecu has no control over fuel and spark, what it tries to do when it hears spark will be irrelevant. The stock ecu can't do anything about it anyways. However, there is the ability to tap into the factory knock sensor and allow the new ecu to control it. It can be done. Whether or not they did this, I don't know. If you stay nonturbo and never intend to go with forced induction, you do not need a knock sensor. If you do, your tuning was seriously messed up and in need of proper attention. For forced induction it is a good idea. I would suspect that they did tap into this. If they didn't, it wouldn't be that hard.
Any difficult questions or more specific questions should really be directly at Mazsport themselves. They are one of our sponsoring vendors now so don't hesitate to ask them questions directly. They are the only ones that can give you an answer with 100% accuracy.
#85
Originally Posted by rotarygod
As far as knock control goes, this too would be another driect question for Mazsport. brillo and myself are working on our own project but unlike this one ours isn't going into production. What ours does and what theirs does is probably similar but there will always be some differences. The stock knock sensor is undoubtedly still hooked up to the stock ecu but since the stock ecu has no control over fuel and spark, what it tries to do when it hears spark will be irrelevant. The stock ecu can't do anything about it anyways. However, there is the ability to tap into the factory knock sensor and allow the new ecu to control it. It can be done. Whether or not they did this, I don't know. If you stay nonturbo and never intend to go with forced induction, you do not need a knock sensor. If you do, your tuning was seriously messed up and in need of proper attention. For forced induction it is a good idea. I would suspect that they did tap into this. If they didn't, it wouldn't be that hard.
The stock ECU has a very sophisticated processing model for knock detection. I suppose a solution would be to monitor the ECU's timing activities against its predicted timing for conditions, and use that different to pull timing. There are also analogue circuits of varying effectiveness that can condition the signal for the ECU. However, none of these are as good as the stock unit's processing.
Last edited by tuj; 08-04-2005 at 06:26 PM.
#87
I've been biting my tongue about this for quite a while now. Scott has had my car since April; he's being nice enough to hold onto it for me while I'm in Iraq, and I've been chatting with him by email . He made me promise not to tell anyone about this stuff until he was ready. I'm on the list for one of the first Interceptors, and also for the machining of the GReddy turbo to put in a larger compressor wheel that RXHusker mentioned. Hopefully when I get back in month and a half, I'll have a quite fast RX-8 waiting for me.
#88
Originally Posted by Nemesis8
What are we going to do about heat in the ECU box??? My CZ gets so hot, I can't touch it. Should the cover be designed with fans that draw air out of the box, thus pulling more flow through the front inlet tube below the bumper?
#89
Originally Posted by Psylence
Yes, please show us the software! I can only hope its less of a chore to muddle through than Motec's archaic stuff.
Saving my pennies for this as we speak! Can't wait to see what it will do on an NA engine.. turbos are yucky
Saving my pennies for this as we speak! Can't wait to see what it will do on an NA engine.. turbos are yucky
Archaic? How can you say that? Do you actually have experience w/MoTeC other than knowing the word? Sorry sport but you said something about the system that others try to emulate. "It's like MoTeC but cheaper and oh yeah it can't do everything that MoTeC can" or " it's like a Rolex only don't go swimming with it"
Ask the winning teams how they like MoTeC.
#90
I knew Charlie would see this! LOL. Give em hell Charlie!
Ok this has unevened the playing field but hey thats life! Let the fun begin!
Yes computer fans can be placed ito help cool the ecu etc. I and others spoke of that over a year ago.Canzoomer folks were also concerned with the heat. Of course they where into stealth so the fans would be a dead giveaway. Point of interest--no cz unit ever failed because of the heat that I am aware off. I dont think this unit will generate anymore heat than that combo. The heat actually comes from the stock ecu. (and engine bay of course). It is a valid question however. If stealth is not an issue hook up 2 (intake and exhaust) computer fans to the stock ecu box(with filters of course) and no worries!
Now least we forget--this is indeed a big breakthrough BUT YOU WILL STILL NEED GOOD TUNING FI OR NA! So all those factors will come into the picture and yes i see economy maps, mountain maps, road track maps and drag maps all kinds of maps. even valet parking maps.
One question I have is the cz was invisable basically --unless you opened the ecu box. Will this unit be that way or would it need to be removed if you went to the dealer?
With this type of control some will surely push the envelope and blow an engine. So lets expect that and not overreact.
Looks like I will be brown bagging to work for a long time. --While I monitor results.
Olddragger
Ps Richard oh Richard where are thou Richard!
Ok this has unevened the playing field but hey thats life! Let the fun begin!
Yes computer fans can be placed ito help cool the ecu etc. I and others spoke of that over a year ago.Canzoomer folks were also concerned with the heat. Of course they where into stealth so the fans would be a dead giveaway. Point of interest--no cz unit ever failed because of the heat that I am aware off. I dont think this unit will generate anymore heat than that combo. The heat actually comes from the stock ecu. (and engine bay of course). It is a valid question however. If stealth is not an issue hook up 2 (intake and exhaust) computer fans to the stock ecu box(with filters of course) and no worries!
Now least we forget--this is indeed a big breakthrough BUT YOU WILL STILL NEED GOOD TUNING FI OR NA! So all those factors will come into the picture and yes i see economy maps, mountain maps, road track maps and drag maps all kinds of maps. even valet parking maps.
One question I have is the cz was invisable basically --unless you opened the ecu box. Will this unit be that way or would it need to be removed if you went to the dealer?
With this type of control some will surely push the envelope and blow an engine. So lets expect that and not overreact.
Looks like I will be brown bagging to work for a long time. --While I monitor results.
Olddragger
Ps Richard oh Richard where are thou Richard!
#93
Marietta, go buy a Motec if you can.. and then tell me how awesome their shitcore DOS software is. It's completely user hostile. I had an M4Pro and loathed that software..
Don't give me this BS about "winning teams".. they can pay the mad loot to get the one guy who can work the software! It SUCKS.
Don't give me this BS about "winning teams".. they can pay the mad loot to get the one guy who can work the software! It SUCKS.
#94
hahaaaha psylence your talking to the guy already with the winning team using motecs http://www.mazcare.com/
quote is to show his racing history
quote is to show his racing history
Originally Posted by Marietta 8
We saw some pretty high temps in the 2nd gen ITS cars early on but got them down to 180-200 w/ducting and even bigger coolers. Bottom line, the guts of the engine bearings and such were not damaged when inspected at teardown but performance certainly was not as good.
I agree that lower temps are more desireable but high temps are not as big a killer as you make them out to be. I was scared shitless when we saw the temps the ITS cars ran but we ran up front for several seasons w/no engine failures thanks to Dr Ianetti and Roger Mandeville. My FC turbo w/MoTeC datalogged oil and water temps of 185-210 deg F in August in Atlanta traffic. Under boost at just shy of 370 rwhp @ 12 psi it would climb 10 deg. The engine has been alive and kickin since 2000 but now lives in a Formula D first gen.
Hope I didn't take up too much space!
I agree that lower temps are more desireable but high temps are not as big a killer as you make them out to be. I was scared shitless when we saw the temps the ITS cars ran but we ran up front for several seasons w/no engine failures thanks to Dr Ianetti and Roger Mandeville. My FC turbo w/MoTeC datalogged oil and water temps of 185-210 deg F in August in Atlanta traffic. Under boost at just shy of 370 rwhp @ 12 psi it would climb 10 deg. The engine has been alive and kickin since 2000 but now lives in a Formula D first gen.
Hope I didn't take up too much space!
#95
Just wondering though at what point do you lose the primary appealing point of the Greddy kit...the price point. Let's assume the kit is about $3000 + $1800 for the standalone system + the other various accesories. At $4,800 you are getting into almost PTP Motorsports Turbo kit area. Wouldn't make more sense to get a T4 turbo system with (possible) Haltech engine management system ? This standalone makes sense for someone like me (who already has a Greddy system), but going forward when (hopefully soon) the PTP comes out at that point will this seem a bit fiscally unfeasible ? Unless, PTP comes out at $5500+.
I would be interested in an air intake for the Greddy kit. SR Motorsports was going to introduce one a few months back (based on their air intake unit) but pulled it because of the issues we were having with our Greddy kits at the time.
Also, the porting of the compressor housing is very interesting. That way those of us with the existing kit won't have to modify the placement of the turbo, or modify the existing exhaust manifold. What compressor wheel would they go to ? From 18G to 20G maybe ?
I would be interested in an air intake for the Greddy kit. SR Motorsports was going to introduce one a few months back (based on their air intake unit) but pulled it because of the issues we were having with our Greddy kits at the time.
Also, the porting of the compressor housing is very interesting. That way those of us with the existing kit won't have to modify the placement of the turbo, or modify the existing exhaust manifold. What compressor wheel would they go to ? From 18G to 20G maybe ?
#96
I'm still stickin by my story. Motec has user hostile SOFTware. Their hardware is not in question.
I'm hoping for something, ya know.. that looks like it was coded this century when it comes to tuning
I'm hoping for something, ya know.. that looks like it was coded this century when it comes to tuning
#97
So for those of us who are sick of waiting,
can we buy the PTP turbo kit that's already complete and
buy this unit? instead of the EMS PTP will be offering?
I know I will have to tune it, but where would I tune this ??
can we buy the PTP turbo kit that's already complete and
buy this unit? instead of the EMS PTP will be offering?
I know I will have to tune it, but where would I tune this ??
#99
OK, for Olddragger and whoever else was droping me hints. I have no doubt that this is a fine unit and would work.
My problem with it is that if I were to sell you all of the componants, meaning Blower, drive, brackets, ducting, belts, nuts and bolts. Hoses, wires and more for say $4000. What sense could it make to up the price 40% to $5600 just to include a box with $100 worth of electronic componants in it?
I'm not knocking them, they feel they need to recover their R&D with so many units sold. I'm just envious that I can't do it. I know I've got more R&D in my compressor then anyone has in a controller.
It just puts our kit out of the target market. You guys would be flaming me for overpricing. If this is the norm I'll commision someone to build me a propriatory unit. It'll take some more time but that's the cookie crumbles. The Mercedes bends.
Just hope RotaryGod and Brillo get that unit working. It should do everything this one does. Except split the plug firing independent.
My problem with it is that if I were to sell you all of the componants, meaning Blower, drive, brackets, ducting, belts, nuts and bolts. Hoses, wires and more for say $4000. What sense could it make to up the price 40% to $5600 just to include a box with $100 worth of electronic componants in it?
I'm not knocking them, they feel they need to recover their R&D with so many units sold. I'm just envious that I can't do it. I know I've got more R&D in my compressor then anyone has in a controller.
It just puts our kit out of the target market. You guys would be flaming me for overpricing. If this is the norm I'll commision someone to build me a propriatory unit. It'll take some more time but that's the cookie crumbles. The Mercedes bends.
Just hope RotaryGod and Brillo get that unit working. It should do everything this one does. Except split the plug firing independent.
#100
Originally Posted by evilbada1
So for those of us who are sick of waiting,
can we buy the PTP turbo kit that's already complete and
buy this unit? instead of the EMS PTP will be offering?
I know I will have to tune it, but where would I tune this ??
can we buy the PTP turbo kit that's already complete and
buy this unit? instead of the EMS PTP will be offering?
I know I will have to tune it, but where would I tune this ??