Ex S2000 owner test drives an RX-8
08-22-2007 | 11:17 AM
#51
I'll snap his neck.
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 1,233
Likes: 2
From: EVOLV-Chicago
Congrats!
As far as getting better than advertised MPG with a Honda - I think this is fairly common. I've gotten 35mpg highway with our 05 TL, and my old neighbors got better than the EPA estimates with their CR-V. My dad has been getting great mileage with his 07 CR-V.
People seem to like to rip on Hondas, but they do know how to make a smooth, fuel-efficent piston engine.
And keep in mind our TL has 258hp and 233 lb-ft of torque. And I got that mileage when driving in the 70-75 mph range.
I have to give them credit for their transmissions too. The TL's automatic tranny shifts very alertly and quickly (and is very smooth).
As far as getting better than advertised MPG with a Honda - I think this is fairly common. I've gotten 35mpg highway with our 05 TL, and my old neighbors got better than the EPA estimates with their CR-V. My dad has been getting great mileage with his 07 CR-V.
People seem to like to rip on Hondas, but they do know how to make a smooth, fuel-efficent piston engine.
And keep in mind our TL has 258hp and 233 lb-ft of torque. And I got that mileage when driving in the 70-75 mph range.
I have to give them credit for their transmissions too. The TL's automatic tranny shifts very alertly and quickly (and is very smooth).
Last edited by mdw1000; 08-22-2007 at 11:21 AM.
08-28-2007 | 02:17 PM
#54
HIDs back in business!
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 358
Likes: 0
From: Probably @ work
Congrats on the purchase. The S2K is a great car (as you already know from owning one). I've never driven one, but I what I read and hear is only ever positive.
I didn't look at the S2K before buying my 8, I've wanted a rotary RX since the FD left the US, but it sure would be nice to have a convertible top and decent MPG!
Good luck with the car.
I didn't look at the S2K before buying my 8, I've wanted a rotary RX since the FD left the US, but it sure would be nice to have a convertible top and decent MPG!
Good luck with the car.
08-28-2007 | 04:01 PM
#56
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 65
Likes: 0
I had an 04 s2k for about 3 years, It was a great car. The tanny is still by far one of the best that i have ever felt.
I have owned an 06 rx8 touring for about a year now. So far no complaints no problems. Had all the recall stuff done, I have no clue what flash im on right now. But other than that its been a great ride so far. It is more comfortable and practical (minus the fuel consumption) than the s2k, I have the bose option and the speakers/radio are 100 times better than in the s2000.
Both cars are amazing. I guess you just have to look at what you need the car for most. S2000 is great fun on the track and just as great on the road. But it does lack the refinement the rx8 has for daily driving practicality and comfort.
I have owned an 06 rx8 touring for about a year now. So far no complaints no problems. Had all the recall stuff done, I have no clue what flash im on right now. But other than that its been a great ride so far. It is more comfortable and practical (minus the fuel consumption) than the s2k, I have the bose option and the speakers/radio are 100 times better than in the s2000.
Both cars are amazing. I guess you just have to look at what you need the car for most. S2000 is great fun on the track and just as great on the road. But it does lack the refinement the rx8 has for daily driving practicality and comfort.
08-28-2007 | 06:07 PM
#57
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 817
Likes: 0
From: Connecticut
08-28-2007 | 06:18 PM
#58
Bummer that your car was stolen, but its fun shopping for a new one, and it sounds like you'd be happy with our beloved 8.
The steering is fantastic in it.
I believe the MX-5 and RX-8 share the same tranny (manual), and for even better shifting the RP shorter shifter is supposed to be amazing (RP makes one for the S2000 too.).
The stock brakes are very good, and since youre used to low gas mileage the RX-8's wont come as a shock to you.
The best part of the car is the handling, if you liked the test drive just wait till you own one and can really flog it.
Regarding the lack of acceleration, I dont know, our car has had so many reflashes of the PCM it may have felt different at one time. A few mods (light flywheel) can help out some.
I believe Ive read on here the GS model (sport package in US) is arount 70llbs lighter, and greater head clearance (for helmets).
I have cloth seats and love them. 30k miles, over 2 1/2 years and they look great.
The steering is fantastic in it.
I believe the MX-5 and RX-8 share the same tranny (manual), and for even better shifting the RP shorter shifter is supposed to be amazing (RP makes one for the S2000 too.).
The stock brakes are very good, and since youre used to low gas mileage the RX-8's wont come as a shock to you.
The best part of the car is the handling, if you liked the test drive just wait till you own one and can really flog it.
Regarding the lack of acceleration, I dont know, our car has had so many reflashes of the PCM it may have felt different at one time. A few mods (light flywheel) can help out some.
I believe Ive read on here the GS model (sport package in US) is arount 70llbs lighter, and greater head clearance (for helmets).
I have cloth seats and love them. 30k miles, over 2 1/2 years and they look great.
08-28-2007 | 10:52 PM
#60
Registered User
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 759
Likes: 0
From: PNW
Do you care to offer some convincing evidence of this seemingly absurd assertion that pops up in this forum from time to time?
08-28-2007 | 10:55 PM
#61
Please see this link here: https://www.rx8club.com/series-i-tech-garage-22/will-blend-s2k-trans-rx8-123318/
EDIT: I knew someone would say something about my previous post.
EDIT: I knew someone would say something about my previous post.
08-30-2007 | 10:28 AM
#65
Registered
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 1,453
Likes: 0
From: Georgetown
I had to get a new tranny (the 3 to 4 shift grinded at redline) so I'm not too pleased with its reliability, although it was covered. As a former Miata driver I thought I had shifting nirvana, but the 8 is even better - as long as the tranny is hot. If you just take it for a 20 minute drive it feels kinda notchy.
08-30-2007 | 11:20 AM
#66
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 59
Likes: 0
From: Montreal
Not really but I guess I just love the RX-8 and am always annoying my friend to let me drive his for kicks.
When I say I'll be getting one ''soon'' it doesn't mean right away though, more like when I have kids:D
I know there's one guy on this forum who has an S2000 and an RX-8 and he seems extremely happy.
I just wish my S2000 had the RX-8 brakes and steering.....And that the RX-8 had the S2000's transmission and engine....
Right now I'm having aluminum steering rack bushings installed in my S2K and next week I'll be getting Hawk HP+ pads to try and make my Honda more ''RX-8'' like
anyways thanks for the info people, you're always very helpful on this forum
When I say I'll be getting one ''soon'' it doesn't mean right away though, more like when I have kids:D
I know there's one guy on this forum who has an S2000 and an RX-8 and he seems extremely happy.
I just wish my S2000 had the RX-8 brakes and steering.....And that the RX-8 had the S2000's transmission and engine....
Right now I'm having aluminum steering rack bushings installed in my S2K and next week I'll be getting Hawk HP+ pads to try and make my Honda more ''RX-8'' like
anyways thanks for the info people, you're always very helpful on this forum
08-30-2007 | 12:00 PM
#67
Grand Chancellor
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 2,730
Likes: 58
From: Home of the NIMBYs
I used to like the miata's shifter. But now that I am used to the smooth rifle-bolt feel of the 8, jumping back into a few NC's manual felt unrefined. It is short and direct no doubt, but it didn't possess the utter smoothness than the 8's tranny exudes. I don't remember the s2k's. Part of my other life is write automotive review for regional rag.... 
I had to get a new tranny (the 3 to 4 shift grinded at redline) so I'm not too pleased with its reliability, although it was covered. As a former Miata driver I thought I had shifting nirvana, but the 8 is even better - as long as the tranny is hot. If you just take it for a 20 minute drive it feels kinda notchy.
08-30-2007 | 07:37 PM
#68
HIDs back in business!
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 358
Likes: 0
From: Probably @ work
Not really but I guess I just love the RX-8 and am always annoying my friend to let me drive his for kicks.
When I say I'll be getting one ''soon'' it doesn't mean right away though, more like when I have kids:D
I know there's one guy on this forum who has an S2000 and an RX-8 and he seems extremely happy.
I just wish my S2000 had the RX-8 brakes and steering.....And that the RX-8 had the S2000's transmission and engine....
Right now I'm having aluminum steering rack bushings installed in my S2K and next week I'll be getting Hawk HP+ pads to try and make my Honda more ''RX-8'' like
anyways thanks for the info people, you're always very helpful on this forum
When I say I'll be getting one ''soon'' it doesn't mean right away though, more like when I have kids:D
I know there's one guy on this forum who has an S2000 and an RX-8 and he seems extremely happy.
I just wish my S2000 had the RX-8 brakes and steering.....And that the RX-8 had the S2000's transmission and engine....
Right now I'm having aluminum steering rack bushings installed in my S2K and next week I'll be getting Hawk HP+ pads to try and make my Honda more ''RX-8'' like
anyways thanks for the info people, you're always very helpful on this forum
I encourage you to restate/rethink your previous comment. I'll help:
"I just wish my S2000 had the RX-8 brakes and steering....And that the RX-8, with its stellar rotary, had 50 more lbs of torque."
09-02-2007 | 12:31 AM
#69
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 79
Likes: 0
I seem to recall back in '04 I had a publication (don't recall who published it) that said the 8 and the S2K had the same gearbox. But it appears they only have the same maker and are similar, not the same. Back then these were the only 2 production cars with CF gearbox parts.
BTW the 8 isn't so great with babies. I find that rear facing babyseats, you have to move the front passenger seat up making it tough for someone to sit there. And it's cramped for my wife when she sits behind me. And its cramped for me cuz I need to pull my seat fwd (shes 5'8"). Good thing we have another car.
BTW the 8 isn't so great with babies. I find that rear facing babyseats, you have to move the front passenger seat up making it tough for someone to sit there. And it's cramped for my wife when she sits behind me. And its cramped for me cuz I need to pull my seat fwd (shes 5'8"). Good thing we have another car.
09-03-2007 | 01:43 PM
#70
Registered User
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 295
Likes: 0
all i can say is, DONT BUY IT if you dont like how slow it is. your not going to make it faster easily.
i ended up selling mine almost 3 years ago now becuase
#1 gas milage was HORRIBLE, i coulda been in a vette going faster and getting better mpg
#2 no torque got very annoying once the idea of a new car went away. mommys honda accord smoked me over and over.
#3 it was always in the damn shop. covered under warranty but still....
i ended up selling mine almost 3 years ago now becuase
#1 gas milage was HORRIBLE, i coulda been in a vette going faster and getting better mpg
#2 no torque got very annoying once the idea of a new car went away. mommys honda accord smoked me over and over.
#3 it was always in the damn shop. covered under warranty but still....
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
SayNoToPistons
NE RX-8 Forum
0
07-29-2015 04:43 PM
