Fundamental Flaw of Rotary?
#26
So every car makers except Mazda is stupid...?
The few companies such as Mercedes Benz that took on rotary engines for a short amount of period then dropped it even though it's a better design fundamentally?
Sorry, as big of a rotary fan as I am, I simply can't imagine the only thing holding down rotary is profitability aspect of it due to the lack of mass production...
If profitability is the only problem, shouldn't all race cars be rotaries since they are "better"?
Sorry, not a engineering guru, just a consumer raising some common sense queries.
The few companies such as Mercedes Benz that took on rotary engines for a short amount of period then dropped it even though it's a better design fundamentally?
Sorry, as big of a rotary fan as I am, I simply can't imagine the only thing holding down rotary is profitability aspect of it due to the lack of mass production...
If profitability is the only problem, shouldn't all race cars be rotaries since they are "better"?
Sorry, not a engineering guru, just a consumer raising some common sense queries.
Mazda was thinking a little different, back then President Mr. Matsuda wants something to represent their brand, some brand image thing. and Rotary seems like a pretty interesting concept and if they can make it work, a lot of people will know Mazda. a lot of people called him nutz. Just like any explorer, ppl always call them nuts.
Aluminum Rotors will solve a lot of problems. but too bad the production cost would be too high.
#27
Even with modern technology like direct fuel injection doesn't seem like it would propel it to where a piston engine producing 230 bhp would get as far as mpg.
Mazda's passion for rotary is awesome, admirable and refreshing. The economic consequences seem to be rather unfortunate. Maybe the other car companies did have the right idea on passing on the rotary concept.
#29
Furthermore, it contains many moving parts increasing the sm total of parts to replace due to wear and tear. Pistons, cylinders (relative to the piston), cam, valves, conrods, crank etc, etc.
The rotary has 6. Genius.
#30
#31
Are you a car enthusiast - or an accountant? As car afficianados, our job is to want the best, most interesting, most forward-thinking, most superior products out there. Let the corporate bean counters kill the rotary engine, BetaMax, and any other smarter, more progressive technology. That's their job – not ours.
#32
Every engine is a collection of compromises...
in fact, that's what engineering is all about: Managing the compromises.
Give me an RX-5 with a nice MS package...
Oh... forgive me... I'm drinking...
in fact, that's what engineering is all about: Managing the compromises.
Give me an RX-5 with a nice MS package...
Oh... forgive me... I'm drinking...
#33
#34
Are you a car enthusiast - or an accountant? As car afficianados, our job is to want the best, most interesting, most forward-thinking, most superior products out there. Let the corporate bean counters kill the rotary engine, BetaMax, and any other smarter, more progressive technology. That's their job – not ours.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Jst4fun
RX-8 Parts For Sale/Wanted
18
04-17-2021 08:43 AM
Jst4fun
RX-8 Parts For Sale/Wanted
9
03-05-2021 08:16 PM
jasonrxeight
RX-8's For Sale/Wanted
2
09-30-2015 02:53 PM