How many of you drive with the DSC/TCS off?
#27
Originally Posted by Glyphon
The only button push that will produce more power is the one connected to the nitrous system.
#28
Originally Posted by saturn
Careful not to push the NOS button too early when racing for slips or you'll get pwned by the other guy. "Too soon junior...."
#30
Here's a thread. I know I'm not the only one who feels a difference.
https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-discussion-3/dynamic-stability-control-dsc-modes-63611/
https://www.rx8club.com/rx-8-discussion-3/dynamic-stability-control-dsc-modes-63611/
#31
aaah. the old reliable butt dyno. and the car can be quicker with the DSC/TCS turned off. but not because it is creating power magically, but because doing so keeps the computer from reducing the power output. this is a very big difference.
#32
Originally Posted by realdeal
fast and the furious reference i bet.
I don't know why you're all splitting hairs about this DSC/TCS business. I don't even have a differential. I love to watch my tires spin like crazy when I make a turn. That's how real car enthusiasts do it.
#33
Originally Posted by DailyDriver2k5
I learned to drive from two well known SCCA memebers that use to work with me when i had my 86 turbo Z. I would always spin out , and never had the confidence behind the wheel of my turbo Z , so i asked them to teach me how to drive a RWD properly and confidently 7 years ago. The rest was history.......
#34
So Glyphon you've never done the long button press? I switch between all 'modes' during the week so I do notice a difference between them. I just feel I get a better response and more acceleration out of the engine.
#35
For long journeys I leave the DSC on, but in the city and short trips I usually switch it off.
Here in snowy Finland it interrupts all the time when your driving in th city... and it does deliver better mpg when you drive without it..
It is a good safety option, but in my opinion, it is smoother to drive without it (at short distances on icy roads). Probably in summer I will leave it on for 70 % off time.
Here in snowy Finland it interrupts all the time when your driving in th city... and it does deliver better mpg when you drive without it..
It is a good safety option, but in my opinion, it is smoother to drive without it (at short distances on icy roads). Probably in summer I will leave it on for 70 % off time.
#36
The RealDeal Test
Originally Posted by realdeal
Here's a thread. I know I'm not the only one who feels a difference.
https://www.rx8club.com/showthread.php?t=63611
https://www.rx8club.com/showthread.php?t=63611
Go out to I-5 in CA... the part between Sacramento and LA.
Fill car to the brim with gas and DSC/TCS on.
Start driving either North or South at 65 mph on cruise control.
Run out of gas and record milage.
Drive back
Fill car to the brin with gass and turn DSC/TCS off.
Repeat the test driving the same direction (must make sure that wind is not different and you dont have an extra passanger at any point).
I bet if you did this and NO ENVIRONMENTAL conditions presented themselves, you would get the within a mile or two actual distance of being the same.
There are so many other conditions that go into fuel milage. I am in full agreement that DSC/TCS wouldnt have anything to do with it!
#37
You are absolutely correct that you will get better acceleration on high mue with the system off. Some tire spin is a good thing for max accel, the problem is that it leads to instability which is what the system is designed to prevent. It does not affect engine power in any way prior to tire spin or excessive yaw (feedback control, not ‘feed-forward’).
I personally leave it on all the time unless I know I'm going to screw around (fairly often). Generally, I have my wife trained to scowl at me pre-emptively when I turn it off instead of actually waiting for the irresponsibility to occur (it's her car, after all).
Sorry for being defensive, most forums are pretty resistant to the engineering perspective preferring the 'myth busters' approach (or, often, the YOU ARE A LIAR approach)
Later,
Alex
I personally leave it on all the time unless I know I'm going to screw around (fairly often). Generally, I have my wife trained to scowl at me pre-emptively when I turn it off instead of actually waiting for the irresponsibility to occur (it's her car, after all).
Sorry for being defensive, most forums are pretty resistant to the engineering perspective preferring the 'myth busters' approach (or, often, the YOU ARE A LIAR approach)
Later,
Alex
#38
Originally Posted by timisw
Alright RealDeal... Try this...
Go out to I-5 in CA... the part between Sacramento and LA.
Fill car to the brim with gas and DSC/TCS on.
Start driving either North or South at 65 mph on cruise control.
Run out of gas and record milage.
Drive back
Fill car to the brin with gass and turn DSC/TCS off.
Repeat the test driving the same direction (must make sure that wind is not different and you dont have an extra passanger at any point).
I bet if you did this and NO ENVIRONMENTAL conditions presented themselves, you would get the within a mile or two actual distance of being the same.
There are so many other conditions that go into fuel milage. I am in full agreement that DSC/TCS wouldnt have anything to do with it!
Go out to I-5 in CA... the part between Sacramento and LA.
Fill car to the brim with gas and DSC/TCS on.
Start driving either North or South at 65 mph on cruise control.
Run out of gas and record milage.
Drive back
Fill car to the brin with gass and turn DSC/TCS off.
Repeat the test driving the same direction (must make sure that wind is not different and you dont have an extra passanger at any point).
I bet if you did this and NO ENVIRONMENTAL conditions presented themselves, you would get the within a mile or two actual distance of being the same.
There are so many other conditions that go into fuel milage. I am in full agreement that DSC/TCS wouldnt have anything to do with it!
You buying the ticket to CA? Beers on me!
#39
Originally Posted by yiksing
So what exactly did they teach you, mind sharing?
Sure.....For starters they rode with me in my turbo Z(took me out to an abandon lot, then some nice transitional S's around my way, poor souls, i know they wanted hurl from my aweful driving back then.)
1. First and formost rule ,GAS WILL SAVE YOUR ***!
2. They taught me how to brake properly before going into a turn. Never plow into a turn with a RWD(which i was doing in my Z) See the turn and execute the turn in your mind then follow through. Always look to hitting the apex of the corner.
3. They taught me never to let off the gas when your already in the turn, causes the tail to come ....very nasty(always did that in my Z, got so nervous when i felt like i was out of control, i would let off, lead to spinouts). Sort of ease the gas pedal down to accelerate if the tail starts to step out. Never mash the gas if the tail comes out, will cause you to spin out or snap back in a uncontrollable and sometime unrecovered fish tail.
4. Once in a turn depending on the legnth and severity of the turn , try and not to shift, shifting causes the weight to shift and could cause you to spin out. If its a long gentle sweeper then more than likely you can shift, if its S's that had quick transistionals just stay in your current gear to get through them.
5. Power out of a turn gracefully instead of forcefully, could result in a spin out.
Some other stuff as well, but i was very humble to watch these two gentlemen at work. Needless to say ,i took into account what they taught me very seriously, because i knew i would be owning more RWD cars in the future at that time, so i really needed to understand how to drive one before i killed myself or someone else in the first RWD car i owned at the time. With practicing over time i became confident in myself and with RWD setups and understanding the power from each RWD car i owned , i became dedicated to learn the limits of each RWD car i own. This way there was no surprises.......
Watching them drive my turboZ as co-pilot even purpousely stepping out the tail then recovering was amazing. These guys ran Formula Fords, ran spec racers and one of the guys ran the SCCA spec RX-7 class.
Unfortunately one of gentlemen passed from Lung cancer and the other still races Spec Rx-7 with his son.
All i can say is , if your passionate about driving and want to learn the most out of your vehicle, i highly recomend going to driving school. I recieved some valuable skills for free, but i would have paid a million times over if i had to relearn those same skills all over.
#40
Originally Posted by realdeal
So Glyphon you've never done the long button press? I switch between all 'modes' during the week so I do notice a difference between them. I just feel I get a better response and more acceleration out of the engine.
there is no difference in power between taht setting and DSC/TCS on. The butt dyno difference is because you are expecting there to be a difference (there isn't one...placebo effect if you will), and the time difference on slips at the drag are from better launches and DSC not cutting power on tirespin at shifts.
you obviously don't get how the system works. go back to the bottom of page 1 and re-read (or for the first time if you haven't yet) esuvee's explaination on how the DSC system works. Summary...it works by closing the throttle and/or applying the brakes, and only in specific situations (such as tire spin or with yaw exceeding a predefined limit). explain to me how braking and closing the throttle in those specific instances produces power?
#41
I ALWAYS TURN IT OFF, its the thing I hate most about the 8...I calculated I spend about 85 hours a year with my finger on that stupid button...I demand that time back!
To drive such a superbly balanced car that restricts your fun is like watching a stripper dance around in flannel pajamas. Whats the point?
And please, PLEASE spare me the "we'll wait to see your car wrapped around a pole"
To drive such a superbly balanced car that restricts your fun is like watching a stripper dance around in flannel pajamas. Whats the point?
And please, PLEASE spare me the "we'll wait to see your car wrapped around a pole"
#42
Originally Posted by 9291150
I ALWAYS TURN IT OFF, its the thing I hate most about the 8...I calculated I spend about 85 hours a year with my finger on that stupid button...I demand that time back!
To drive such a superbly balanced car that restricts your fun is like watching a stripper dance around in flannel pajamas. Whats the point?
And please, PLEASE spare me the "we'll wait to see your car wrapped around a pole"
To drive such a superbly balanced car that restricts your fun is like watching a stripper dance around in flannel pajamas. Whats the point?
And please, PLEASE spare me the "we'll wait to see your car wrapped around a pole"
#47
Originally Posted by Glyphon
yes, i have held the button down for the 7 seconds to get the DSC OFF and Traction Control lights on the dash to illuminate.
there is no difference in power between taht setting and DSC/TCS on. The butt dyno difference is because you are expecting there to be a difference (there isn't one...placebo effect if you will), and the time difference on slips at the drag are from better launches and DSC not cutting power on tirespin at shifts.
you obviously don't get how the system works. go back to the bottom of page 1 and re-read (or for the first time if you haven't yet) esuvee's explaination on how the DSC system works. Summary...it works by closing the throttle and/or applying the brakes, and only in specific situations (such as tire spin or with yaw exceeding a predefined limit). explain to me how braking and closing the throttle in those specific instances produces power?
there is no difference in power between taht setting and DSC/TCS on. The butt dyno difference is because you are expecting there to be a difference (there isn't one...placebo effect if you will), and the time difference on slips at the drag are from better launches and DSC not cutting power on tirespin at shifts.
you obviously don't get how the system works. go back to the bottom of page 1 and re-read (or for the first time if you haven't yet) esuvee's explaination on how the DSC system works. Summary...it works by closing the throttle and/or applying the brakes, and only in specific situations (such as tire spin or with yaw exceeding a predefined limit). explain to me how braking and closing the throttle in those specific instances produces power?
#49
Originally Posted by expo1
DSC will one day be on all cars because it has been the most effective safety device added to cars in the last 10 plus years LINK
This board has many threads of people getting into accidents because for some unknown reason they turned off the DSC on the street. With all the distractions in and outside of your car saying, “ I am an excellent driver, I don’t need DSC ” is just foolish thinking. Driving on the track is a different story. US drivers by in large don’t even check their tire pressure (Gov. mandated TPMS LINK )How can you expect drivers to take the time to learn how to drive their cars under extreme conditions? Having driving my 8 at track speeds with & without DSC your not missing much driving on the street with DSC.
This board has many threads of people getting into accidents because for some unknown reason they turned off the DSC on the street. With all the distractions in and outside of your car saying, “ I am an excellent driver, I don’t need DSC ” is just foolish thinking. Driving on the track is a different story. US drivers by in large don’t even check their tire pressure (Gov. mandated TPMS LINK )How can you expect drivers to take the time to learn how to drive their cars under extreme conditions? Having driving my 8 at track speeds with & without DSC your not missing much driving on the street with DSC.
I think you're blowing things out of this galaxy. YOu can't say that turning dsc off is the reason for accidents when you have no Idea what skill level the driver posesses. The car doesn't drive itself and driving without dsc is far safer then you make it out to be. I think the bigger problem is inexperienced drivers that get use to the training wheel system and then turns it off. I have no dsc at all. Sure it's more challenging to drive fast but it's nothing new. The only thing dsc does well is keeping the vehicle straight when driving in the snow/slippery surfaces. Otherwise, it's totally useless IMO.
#50
Originally Posted by 9291150
I ALWAYS TURN IT OFF, its the thing I hate most about the 8...I calculated I spend about 85 hours a year with my finger on that stupid button...I demand that time back!
To drive such a superbly balanced car that restricts your fun is like watching a stripper dance around in flannel pajamas. Whats the point?
And please, PLEASE spare me the "we'll wait to see your car wrapped around a pole"
To drive such a superbly balanced car that restricts your fun is like watching a stripper dance around in flannel pajamas. Whats the point?
And please, PLEASE spare me the "we'll wait to see your car wrapped around a pole"