In the long run...what is better Auto or Manual?
#3
Registered
Better for what? Your criteria could be entirely different than mine - if the most important thing is how comfortable and easy it is for your 2 hour each way commute in stop-n-go traffic, then you might feel the auto is better. If you're concerned about resale value in 3 years, then I'd suggest that the manual trans is better... You'll have to go into more detail with your question if you want any meaningful answers.
Regards,
Gordon
Regards,
Gordon
#4
Gas mileage: manual (if they were the same power... hehe)
Longevity: manual
Service: manual
Fun: manual
Ease of use: auto
Sadly 90% of America can't drive a manual car so the remaining 10% of us really get happy when we're behind the wheel!
Longevity: manual
Service: manual
Fun: manual
Ease of use: auto
Sadly 90% of America can't drive a manual car so the remaining 10% of us really get happy when we're behind the wheel!
![Smilie](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#8
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Arlington, TX
Posts: 146
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
OK thanks for the replies guys. Now I just need to convince my dad that I want a Manual. If he disagress, won't matter because he is still paying for my RX-8. Yes I am a newbie driver. I drove for about 2 years now.
#9
Registered
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Philadelphia, PA USA
Posts: 1,116
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well, good for you man!!!! There are so few young folks these days looking to learn how to drive manual that I think it's great.
I have no idea what part of the world you are in, but if you are in the US then your biggest problem might be finding a teacher for manual trans, but they are cheaper to buy in general and with the Mazda you get a whole lot more car. The major down side here in the US is that the resale value of manuals is normally less than a comparable automatic because you are substantially limiting the market for the car on resale. That might be a hang up for your dad. But man if you want the most out of this car . . . manual is the way to go.
-H
I have no idea what part of the world you are in, but if you are in the US then your biggest problem might be finding a teacher for manual trans, but they are cheaper to buy in general and with the Mazda you get a whole lot more car. The major down side here in the US is that the resale value of manuals is normally less than a comparable automatic because you are substantially limiting the market for the car on resale. That might be a hang up for your dad. But man if you want the most out of this car . . . manual is the way to go.
-H
#10
man i wish my old man would have got me a 30,000 car when i was a kid.just tell your dad that a manual will improve your driver skills and get better gas mileage,i could work?
#11
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Brisvegas, Aust
Posts: 377
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Haze
Well, good for you man!!!! There are so few young folks these days looking to learn how to drive manual that I think it's great.
Well, good for you man!!!! There are so few young folks these days looking to learn how to drive manual that I think it's great.
In fact, I don't know a single guy with an auto-only license. I know quite a few girls with them though.
Auto or manual? The only auto car I've ever owned, I spent $2500 on converting to manual
![Smilie](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/smile.gif)
-pete
#12
Originally posted by Bankotsu
What about all the stories I hear about manual being in the shops because of something? I am sorry, I am not that intelligent with cars.
What about all the stories I hear about manual being in the shops because of something? I am sorry, I am not that intelligent with cars.
#13
Prodigal Wankler
Originally posted by rpm_pwr
Is this true or an exageration? In Australia (at least where I've been) all males are expected to learn manual. In fact, I don't know a single guy with an auto-only license.
Is this true or an exageration? In Australia (at least where I've been) all males are expected to learn manual. In fact, I don't know a single guy with an auto-only license.
It's another sad fact that most folks here never engage the handbrake. Perhaps that's why they refer to it as an "emergency brake." Hill starts are done with the left foot on the brake and the right on the gas, and parked vehicles are left rocking on the transmission in "Park".
I borrowed a friend's Saturn one day, and pulled the handbrake when I parked it. He thought I'd broken his car because it wouldn't move when he engaged reverse to back out of my driveway!
#14
There are many factors to consider when choosing transmission type, but the primary factor is likely to be either driving experience or driving environment (i.e. stop n' go commuting).
The effect on resale value can be affected by the type of car. The RX-8 is inteded as an enthusiasts car, and the significant power difference between auto and manual models will help the resale values of the manual transmission. Corollas, neons, camry's and other mainstream midsize cars are adversely affected with a manual. But how many people really buy a car because of high residual values? (they are a distinct minority) A new car is a depreciating asset, to expect otherwise is foolish (there are exceptions, I know)
As for maintenance issues, I currently own a 95 Beretta that just turned 140,000 miles on the original clutch - and I am not perfect all the time. It is a self adjusting hydraulic clutch (for whatever that's worth), so there may be some wear advantages with this type. Most of the horror stories from the last 2 years regarding 6 speed celicas and RSX's come from those who were not paying attention or racing, and missed a shift (i.e. while coming from 5th gear at 6500 RPM, they miss 6th, drop to 4th, and over-rev the engine). Other maintenance issues are derived from clutch riders. My thought on this is only depress the clutch when changing gears, although clutch slipping from a stop on a hill is necessary if someone is behind you.
Regarding driver control....multi-tasking (talking on the phone while eating, applying make-up or other preening processes) is nearly impossible with a manual transmission. I have been guilty of it myself, I am a hypocrite. But I did get a handsfree device for my cell phone (less than $25 US), and is the only way I use the phone in the car. Lesson here: Never try to do too much at 70 MPH!
Finally - choose the tranny the fits your needs/desires, if you can. Ultimately, if you buy the car and don't like, I think the RX-8 will be easy to sell in the secondary market regardless of tranny type (at least for the 1st 12 months after release).
The effect on resale value can be affected by the type of car. The RX-8 is inteded as an enthusiasts car, and the significant power difference between auto and manual models will help the resale values of the manual transmission. Corollas, neons, camry's and other mainstream midsize cars are adversely affected with a manual. But how many people really buy a car because of high residual values? (they are a distinct minority) A new car is a depreciating asset, to expect otherwise is foolish (there are exceptions, I know)
As for maintenance issues, I currently own a 95 Beretta that just turned 140,000 miles on the original clutch - and I am not perfect all the time. It is a self adjusting hydraulic clutch (for whatever that's worth), so there may be some wear advantages with this type. Most of the horror stories from the last 2 years regarding 6 speed celicas and RSX's come from those who were not paying attention or racing, and missed a shift (i.e. while coming from 5th gear at 6500 RPM, they miss 6th, drop to 4th, and over-rev the engine). Other maintenance issues are derived from clutch riders. My thought on this is only depress the clutch when changing gears, although clutch slipping from a stop on a hill is necessary if someone is behind you.
Regarding driver control....multi-tasking (talking on the phone while eating, applying make-up or other preening processes) is nearly impossible with a manual transmission. I have been guilty of it myself, I am a hypocrite. But I did get a handsfree device for my cell phone (less than $25 US), and is the only way I use the phone in the car. Lesson here: Never try to do too much at 70 MPH!
Finally - choose the tranny the fits your needs/desires, if you can. Ultimately, if you buy the car and don't like, I think the RX-8 will be easy to sell in the secondary market regardless of tranny type (at least for the 1st 12 months after release).
#15
Slower traffic keep right
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Orlando
Posts: 225
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by rpm_pwr
Is this true or an exageration? In Australia (at least where I've been) all males are expected to learn manual.
Is this true or an exageration? In Australia (at least where I've been) all males are expected to learn manual.
#17
Coming thru in waves...
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Somewhere between Yesterday and Tomorrow.
Posts: 1,488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Haze
The major down side here in the US is that the resale value of manuals is normally less than a comparable automatic because you are substantially limiting the market for the car on resale. That might be a hang up for your dad.
The major down side here in the US is that the resale value of manuals is normally less than a comparable automatic because you are substantially limiting the market for the car on resale. That might be a hang up for your dad.
#18
rotary courage
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: :uoıʇɐɔoן
Posts: 1,208
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by RXhusker
As someone so appropriately said:
"Manuals are for people who LOVE TO DRIVE, Automatics are for people who love to steer"
As someone so appropriately said:
"Manuals are for people who LOVE TO DRIVE, Automatics are for people who love to steer"
"Automatics are for people who love to talk on their cell phone and sip their latte" :p
#19
Coming thru in waves...
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Somewhere between Yesterday and Tomorrow.
Posts: 1,488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by desmo996
And yet another reason why the U.S. doesn't have good F1 drivers and why NASCAR is so popular.
And yet another reason why the U.S. doesn't have good F1 drivers and why NASCAR is so popular.
![Confused](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/confused.gif)
#20
Slower traffic keep right
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Orlando
Posts: 225
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Racer X-8
Uh, NASCAR cars are all strictly manual, F1 has trick shifter schemes that are almost like automatics. I don't see the parallel here, sorry.
Uh, NASCAR cars are all strictly manual, F1 has trick shifter schemes that are almost like automatics. I don't see the parallel here, sorry.
![Confused](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/confused.gif)
" There is a left turn... do i need to shift? Nah... Crap... another left turn .... shift.... nah.....another left turn...... shift?.... Nah... Maybe I'll slow down..... Actually I don't neeed to slow down because my car has restrictors anyway... Oh **** ....another left turn!!!
People who learn to drive stick tend to have a better understanding of car dynamics and performance. My wife learned and only drove A/T. I forced her to buy a manual and she loves it. She says she has much better control of the car and definately a much better car driver. I very sure Juan Pablo Montoya grew up with A/T (Sarcasm). :p
#21
No more parachute
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Lake Mary, FL
Posts: 261
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The resale value between an auto and a manual car is not that much. It's no more than a few hundred bucks ($200-$400). That's certainly less than the original sticker price to add the auto option. But that's only true for regular cars. In performance cars, the price difference is even less. There's instance where a manual will carry a premium over an auto.
From what I see here in Florida, more females drive manual than males.
From what I see here in Florida, more females drive manual than males.
#22
There's instance where a manual will carry a premium over an auto.
I was also looking for 6-speed Type II Legend coupes. Only found one, and they played the rare card. Would have rather been rolling in that had a mechanics inspection not found quite a bit wrong with it that the seller was unwilling to compensate for.
Same token, an auto RX-8 may be somewhat of a rarity in the future, so someone might be willing to pay a bit more for one.
#25
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Denver, CO, USA
Posts: 2,045
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by desmo996
And yet another reason why the U.S. doesn't have good F1 drivers and why NASCAR is so popular.
And yet another reason why the U.S. doesn't have good F1 drivers and why NASCAR is so popular.
The reason why the U.S. currently doesn't have good F1 drivers is because most U.S. drivers grew up watching U.S. racing series, and therefore ascribed to them instead, and they will normally go where the money takes them. It's along the same lines of more U.S. boys growing up wanting to play baseball, basketball, or football, than going overseas to play rugby or soccer.
---jps