My plan to address the power issue
#76
I just wanted to let you know, abou this website:
http://www.yawpower.com/tqvshp.html
"Buger" posted this in another thread. The above articles within the webpage he posted talks about HP, torque, acceleration in a very nice and clear fashion -- giving lots of insightful understandings about should I worry abou HP, torque, etc. The guy is focused on the rotaries, but the infroomation he gives is of course generic and based on physics -- its well written so you don't have to be a physics major or math expert to understand it....
http://www.yawpower.com/tqvshp.html
"Buger" posted this in another thread. The above articles within the webpage he posted talks about HP, torque, acceleration in a very nice and clear fashion -- giving lots of insightful understandings about should I worry abou HP, torque, etc. The guy is focused on the rotaries, but the infroomation he gives is of course generic and based on physics -- its well written so you don't have to be a physics major or math expert to understand it....
#77
I just made some calculations using the formulas from the above webpage (yawpower...).
I have an RX8 on order and am excited about it, based on my driving experience with it, it was great.
Below is a reporting of the "rate of acceleration" in G's (multiples of the gravity constant), in both 1st and 2nd gear, for several cars:
(below stats on got from their websites)
Honda Civic LX: 110 torque, 2474 lbs curb weight, 1st gear=3.462:1, 2nd gear=1.870:1, final drive=4.070:1
BMW 330Ci: 214 torque, 3285 lbs, 1st = 4.21, 2nd = 2.49, final = 2.93.
RX8: 159 torque, 3000 lbs, 1st = 3.760, 2nd = 2.269, final = 4.444
G35: 270 torque, 3450 lbs, 1st = 3.794, 2nd = 2.324, final = 3.536
350Z: 274 torque, 3247 lbs (touring), 1st = 3.794, 2nd = 2.324, final = 3.536
Car 1st 2nd
--------------------------------
Honda 0.63G 0.33G
BMW 0.80G 0.47G
RX8 0.70G 0.53G
G35 1.05G 0.64G
350Z 1.13G 0.69G
......RX8 is still cool for me!
I have an RX8 on order and am excited about it, based on my driving experience with it, it was great.
Below is a reporting of the "rate of acceleration" in G's (multiples of the gravity constant), in both 1st and 2nd gear, for several cars:
(below stats on got from their websites)
Honda Civic LX: 110 torque, 2474 lbs curb weight, 1st gear=3.462:1, 2nd gear=1.870:1, final drive=4.070:1
BMW 330Ci: 214 torque, 3285 lbs, 1st = 4.21, 2nd = 2.49, final = 2.93.
RX8: 159 torque, 3000 lbs, 1st = 3.760, 2nd = 2.269, final = 4.444
G35: 270 torque, 3450 lbs, 1st = 3.794, 2nd = 2.324, final = 3.536
350Z: 274 torque, 3247 lbs (touring), 1st = 3.794, 2nd = 2.324, final = 3.536
Car 1st 2nd
--------------------------------
Honda 0.63G 0.33G
BMW 0.80G 0.47G
RX8 0.70G 0.53G
G35 1.05G 0.64G
350Z 1.13G 0.69G
......RX8 is still cool for me!
#79
And the above data is "peak power", meaing the G's vary according to the RPM, so in reality I should show you a graph per car, but that's a lot of computation for me now. Any MS Excel geeks can give it a try...
#80
Originally posted by superocho
And the above data is "peak power", meaing the G's vary according to the RPM, so in reality I should show you a graph per car, but that's a lot of computation for me now. Any MS Excel geeks can give it a try...
And the above data is "peak power", meaing the G's vary according to the RPM, so in reality I should show you a graph per car, but that's a lot of computation for me now. Any MS Excel geeks can give it a try...
I think what you were trying to compute was G's at peak torque not peak power.
I did a similar thing a couple of months ago in the below post:
https://www.rx8club.com/showthread.p...5770#post75770
but we seem to have come up with different #s. Are you sure you are computing things correctly?
Brian
#81
The formula I used was the one at the bottom of the webpage:
http://www.yawpower.com/tqvshp.html
We used different numbers. For one, I assumed 1-ft radius wheels. You did 18" which is more accurate, my fault for being lazy. I used that same size for all makes. I think G/8/Z all have 18" inches, so the relative numbers are correct but not the absolute. You also used more weight than me. I used the posted vehicle weight, no drivers etc. Somehow these approximations balance out but I guess sway towards one side.
I had not seem you post before -- looks great! If I get a chance (or you ), I'll try to use your Mr. Yaw's formulas to make a graph for all relevant graphs, like yours, and use correct wheel sizes.
Thanks!
http://www.yawpower.com/tqvshp.html
We used different numbers. For one, I assumed 1-ft radius wheels. You did 18" which is more accurate, my fault for being lazy. I used that same size for all makes. I think G/8/Z all have 18" inches, so the relative numbers are correct but not the absolute. You also used more weight than me. I used the posted vehicle weight, no drivers etc. Somehow these approximations balance out but I guess sway towards one side.
I had not seem you post before -- looks great! If I get a chance (or you ), I'll try to use your Mr. Yaw's formulas to make a graph for all relevant graphs, like yours, and use correct wheel sizes.
Thanks!
#82
Took me a while to read through all this today, but here's a few things that might help:
1. Run Flat tires - they usually weigh in the range of ~60lbs a piece, that will affect a dyno run. Mini Cooper S is an example, each rim/tire weight about 60lbs.
2. DBW Throttle - Simply use an obdii tool to read the % that the throttle is open. That was a potential concern each time. I have two different obdii tools, and hopefully I can read that value if I buy an RX8.
3. Stability/traction control (name?) - is there a switch to turn it off? If it's kicking in because of a speed difference between the two rear wheels, it's probably kicking in and applying brakes?
Just a few rants off the top of my head, sorry for not knowing the car that well yet. I've been tuning for a LONG time, and I've only gone as far as sitting in the RX8. I love it, and I'm stripping the 03 GTI down to stock tonight, and going for a test drive tomorrow
1. Run Flat tires - they usually weigh in the range of ~60lbs a piece, that will affect a dyno run. Mini Cooper S is an example, each rim/tire weight about 60lbs.
2. DBW Throttle - Simply use an obdii tool to read the % that the throttle is open. That was a potential concern each time. I have two different obdii tools, and hopefully I can read that value if I buy an RX8.
3. Stability/traction control (name?) - is there a switch to turn it off? If it's kicking in because of a speed difference between the two rear wheels, it's probably kicking in and applying brakes?
Just a few rants off the top of my head, sorry for not knowing the car that well yet. I've been tuning for a LONG time, and I've only gone as far as sitting in the RX8. I love it, and I'm stripping the 03 GTI down to stock tonight, and going for a test drive tomorrow
#83
1. the car does not have run flats
2. good thought someone else did suggest that but to my knowledge no one had done it.
3.yes, there is a switch, it can be used to completely disable the traction/stability control systems and runs were done with it off.
edit:oops! hello and welcome!
2. good thought someone else did suggest that but to my knowledge no one had done it.
3.yes, there is a switch, it can be used to completely disable the traction/stability control systems and runs were done with it off.
edit:oops! hello and welcome!
#85
This thread used to be about what BOOSTD 7 was going to do to address the power issue (and hopefully the mpg issue which still looms huge to many of us.) Since the thread has been hijacked so badly, I wonder if we can get back on topic. Any update on this, Boost? The Oct deadline is coming up soon and I'm still holding onto my paperwork. I appreciate any inroads you can make on our collective behalf with Mazda.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Audio Concepts ATL
New Member Forum
21
09-26-2021 01:59 PM
Touge
Canada Forum
0
08-13-2015 04:48 AM