SCCA B-Stock Tire/Shock questions
#1
SCCA B-Stock Tire/Shock questions
First question is 2 parts, regarding running B Stock, wheels need to stay same dimensions (within tolerances), but they don't really explain tire sizes.
A) Can I use a wider track (235 vs 225)?
B) Can I use a lower profile (40 vs 45)?
The comment that they must fit within the wheel wells without mods suggests I can go the widest, lowest profile that will fit on the rims.
Second question is re Shocks: What is an "Adjustable Spring Perch"? Is this a coil over with the spring adjustment?
"Adjustable spring perches are allowed, but the spring loadbearing
surface must be in the same location relative to the
shock mounting points as on the standard part. Shims may be
used to achieve compliance."
Third: The rules state "No more than two separate external shock damping adjustment controls. Gas pressure adjustment is not considered a
damping adjustment." Okay so one adjustment for bump, one for return. What can adjustable gas pressure do for me, that the dampers can't?
Thanks
A) Can I use a wider track (235 vs 225)?
B) Can I use a lower profile (40 vs 45)?
The comment that they must fit within the wheel wells without mods suggests I can go the widest, lowest profile that will fit on the rims.
Second question is re Shocks: What is an "Adjustable Spring Perch"? Is this a coil over with the spring adjustment?
"Adjustable spring perches are allowed, but the spring loadbearing
surface must be in the same location relative to the
shock mounting points as on the standard part. Shims may be
used to achieve compliance."
Third: The rules state "No more than two separate external shock damping adjustment controls. Gas pressure adjustment is not considered a
damping adjustment." Okay so one adjustment for bump, one for return. What can adjustable gas pressure do for me, that the dampers can't?
Thanks
#2
05-08 SCCA BS Natl Champ
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by pcimino
First question is 2 parts, regarding running B Stock, wheels need to stay same dimensions (within tolerances), but they don't really explain tire sizes.
A) Can I use a wider track (235 vs 225)?
B) Can I use a lower profile (40 vs 45)?
The comment that they must fit within the wheel wells without mods suggests I can go the widest, lowest profile that will fit on the rims.
Second question is re Shocks: What is an "Adjustable Spring Perch"? Is this a coil over with the spring adjustment?
"Adjustable spring perches are allowed, but the spring loadbearing
surface must be in the same location relative to the
shock mounting points as on the standard part. Shims may be
used to achieve compliance."
Third: The rules state "No more than two separate external shock damping adjustment controls. Gas pressure adjustment is not considered a
damping adjustment." Okay so one adjustment for bump, one for return. What can adjustable gas pressure do for me, that the dampers can't?
Thanks
A) Can I use a wider track (235 vs 225)?
B) Can I use a lower profile (40 vs 45)?
The comment that they must fit within the wheel wells without mods suggests I can go the widest, lowest profile that will fit on the rims.
Second question is re Shocks: What is an "Adjustable Spring Perch"? Is this a coil over with the spring adjustment?
"Adjustable spring perches are allowed, but the spring loadbearing
surface must be in the same location relative to the
shock mounting points as on the standard part. Shims may be
used to achieve compliance."
Third: The rules state "No more than two separate external shock damping adjustment controls. Gas pressure adjustment is not considered a
damping adjustment." Okay so one adjustment for bump, one for return. What can adjustable gas pressure do for me, that the dampers can't?
Thanks
The spring perch must be in the stock location, you can not change ride height by adjusting spring perch location.
The most shocks with two adjustments are compression and rebound. What the gas pressure can be used for is some added spring rate. The downside is if you have high pressure gas shocks it will raise your ride height.
#3
Okay, I', assuming "Spring Perch" is the adjustable screw on the outside of the shock for raising or lowering the spring. Is this the same thing as a coil over? If not, what is a coil over?
#4
coil over means coil-over-spring, basically any suspension in which the spring is around the shock, and the shock is not a load-bearing member (which would be a strut). The Miata and the RX-8 have coil over suspensions, although they are not adjustable.
Most people take 'coilovers' to mean shock/spring combinations that allow adjustment of the upper and/or lower spring perches. This can have the effect of lowering the ride height, increasing the spring rate, or both.
Most people take 'coilovers' to mean shock/spring combinations that allow adjustment of the upper and/or lower spring perches. This can have the effect of lowering the ride height, increasing the spring rate, or both.
#5
No respecter of malarkey
iTrader: (25)
Originally Posted by ULLLOSE
What the gas pressure can be used for is some added spring rate.
not really, that's a false perception. Unlike a spring, the gas pressure force remains relatively constant during suspension movement while the magnitude of spring force changes greatly. Spring rate is force relative to travel, gas pressure applied to the area of the shock shaft is simply force.
#7
05-08 SCCA BS Natl Champ
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by TeamRX8
not really, that's a false perception. Unlike a spring, the gas pressure force remains relatively constant during suspension movement while the magnitude of spring force changes greatly. Spring rate is force relative to travel, gas pressure applied to the area of the shock shaft is simply force.
http://www.monroe.com/tech_support/t...kabsorbers.asp
" An additional benefit of gas charging is that it creates a mild boost in spring rate to the vehicle. This does not mean that a gas charged shock would raise the vehicle up to correct ride height if the springs were sagging. It does help reduce body roll, sway, brake dive, and acceleration squat. "
Also when we were working with Penske on shocks for the vette they told us we could get around 15lbs of spring rate for every 100psi in the shocks.
Last edited by ULLLOSE; 08-17-2005 at 04:32 PM.
#8
No respecter of malarkey
iTrader: (25)
well it's just misrepresented wrong. It does add a static, fixed force, but again spring rate is a dynamic, changing force. Feel free to discuss it with Lee or Jay in the Koni truck at Nationals.
Even the experts make mistakes or generalities that aren't always what they seem.
Even the experts make mistakes or generalities that aren't always what they seem.
Last edited by TeamRX8; 08-18-2005 at 08:35 AM.
#9
05-08 SCCA BS Natl Champ
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by TeamRX8
well it's just misrepresented wrong. It does add a static, fixed force, but again spring rate is a dynamic, changing force. Feel free to discuss it with Lee or Jay in the Koni truck at Nationals.
I regret that you don't know enough to know better; don't always believe what you read. Even the experts make mistakes or generalities that aren't always what they seem.
I regret that you don't know enough to know better; don't always believe what you read. Even the experts make mistakes or generalities that aren't always what they seem.
![Wink](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/wink.gif)
I will agree that it does not add dynamic force. However it does add a static resistance which is a good bandaid for lack of spring rate in a stock class where springs cant be changed. It does still have the drawback of taller ride height.
#10
No respecter of malarkey
iTrader: (25)
it's all a matter or magnitude/relativity, the relativty on a softly sprung Ford Escort is not the same as a Z06 Vette
the fact that it's not a rate means it has little impact on dive/squat as proposed, those rates are controlled by shock valving rather than gas force, it will effect the magnitude some, but the actual magnitude of those generalities are quite small, to the point of being inconsequential in competition driving.
it's not a good bandaid at all, but again I'm sure the real experts like the Motorsports guys from Koni can explain it better to you at Nationals than myself.
the fact that it's not a rate means it has little impact on dive/squat as proposed, those rates are controlled by shock valving rather than gas force, it will effect the magnitude some, but the actual magnitude of those generalities are quite small, to the point of being inconsequential in competition driving.
it's not a good bandaid at all, but again I'm sure the real experts like the Motorsports guys from Koni can explain it better to you at Nationals than myself.
Last edited by TeamRX8; 08-18-2005 at 08:38 AM.
#11
05-08 SCCA BS Natl Champ
iTrader: (1)
Originally Posted by TeamRX8
it's all a matter or magnitude/relativity, the relativty on a softly sprung Ford Escort is not the same as a Z06 Vette
the fact that it's not a rate means it has little impact on dive/squat as proposed, those rates are controlled by shock valving rather than gas force, it will effect the magnitude some, but again your general book knowledge prevents you from appreciating the actual magnitude of reality. The actual magnitude of those generalities are quite small, to the point of being inconsequential in competition driving.
it's not a good bandaid at all, book reading does not trump practical experience but don't take my word on it, talk to the motorsport shock experts at Nationals.
the fact that it's not a rate means it has little impact on dive/squat as proposed, those rates are controlled by shock valving rather than gas force, it will effect the magnitude some, but again your general book knowledge prevents you from appreciating the actual magnitude of reality. The actual magnitude of those generalities are quite small, to the point of being inconsequential in competition driving.
it's not a good bandaid at all, book reading does not trump practical experience but don't take my word on it, talk to the motorsport shock experts at Nationals.
#12
No respecter of malarkey
iTrader: (25)
a replacement one won't be of any noticeable benefit for Stock, if you somehow took that post to mean none at all doesn't matter you were mistaken, or have you simply resorted to egging me on because you can't respond technically?
fwiw, I used to believe the same thing, but I was taught otherwise by people in the damper industry
fwiw, I used to believe the same thing, but I was taught otherwise by people in the damper industry
Last edited by TeamRX8; 08-18-2005 at 08:42 AM.
#13
What's next?
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: SE Mass
Posts: 1,087
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by TeamRX8
a replacement one won't be of any noticeable benefit for Stock, if you somehow took that post to mean none at all doesn't matter I'm not surprised ![Roll Eyes (Sarcastic)](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/rolleyes.gif)
if it makes you feel any better I used to believe the same thing, apparently I happened to be a bit more open minded about it when someone showed me otherwise ...
![Roll Eyes (Sarcastic)](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/rolleyes.gif)
if it makes you feel any better I used to believe the same thing, apparently I happened to be a bit more open minded about it when someone showed me otherwise ...
I just don't think it is possible.
Mark... really. You're kinda rough around the edges... and it's those above statements from you that makes the n00bs scared to post questions.
Can you just keep things to facts without going out and attacking everyone that you happen to disagree with on any particular day?
--kC
#14
No respecter of malarkey
iTrader: (25)
well it started off that way, but then there was this
but I apologize for letting myself get egged on. Jaspon's a great driver, but his characterization of the gas pressure force was incorrect. That's all I originally intended to clarify on. I went back and cleaned up various snippets, I appreciate what you're saying Keith, thanks for the reminder.
Originally Posted by ULLLOSE
These guy dont agree with you, but what would they know:
.
.
Last edited by TeamRX8; 08-18-2005 at 08:44 AM.
#15
Great info...
Okay, so now B Stock states 2 adjustments allowed on a shock (I assume compression and rebound adjustments). But searching for upgrades I keep seeing things like 16 way or 40 way adjustable??? Are these just settings on the dial selector for the damper and they're just saying you can fine tune the stiffness? I see stuff like the dial selector adjusts both rebound and compression. Do I care? Or do I want truly dual adjustable?
The JIC Coilovers look great but are these B Stock legal. What else is available? Everyone talks about the Konis, my concern there is I don't want to remove them to adjust the rears. Does Tokico have a setup for the RX-8 yet?
What brands have kits for the Rx-8? Pros, cons? And remember I want to stay in B-Stock.
Thanks.
Okay, so now B Stock states 2 adjustments allowed on a shock (I assume compression and rebound adjustments). But searching for upgrades I keep seeing things like 16 way or 40 way adjustable??? Are these just settings on the dial selector for the damper and they're just saying you can fine tune the stiffness? I see stuff like the dial selector adjusts both rebound and compression. Do I care? Or do I want truly dual adjustable?
The JIC Coilovers look great but are these B Stock legal. What else is available? Everyone talks about the Konis, my concern there is I don't want to remove them to adjust the rears. Does Tokico have a setup for the RX-8 yet?
What brands have kits for the Rx-8? Pros, cons? And remember I want to stay in B-Stock.
Thanks.
#16
What's next?
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: SE Mass
Posts: 1,087
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by pcimino
Great info...
Okay, so now B Stock states 2 adjustments allowed on a shock (I assume compression and rebound adjustments). But searching for upgrades I keep seeing things like 16 way or 40 way adjustable??? Are these just settings on the dial selector for the damper and they're just saying you can fine tune the stiffness?
Okay, so now B Stock states 2 adjustments allowed on a shock (I assume compression and rebound adjustments). But searching for upgrades I keep seeing things like 16 way or 40 way adjustable??? Are these just settings on the dial selector for the damper and they're just saying you can fine tune the stiffness?
No more than two separate external shock damping adjustment controls. Gas pressure adjustment is not considered a damping adjustment.
I see stuff like the dial selector adjusts both rebound and compression. Do I care? Or do I want truly dual adjustable?
![Wink](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/wink.gif)
The JIC Coilovers look great but are these B Stock legal.
What else is available? Everyone talks about the Konis, my concern there is I don't want to remove them to adjust the rears.
Does Tokico have a setup for the RX-8 yet?
What brands have kits for the Rx-8? Pros, cons? And remember I want to stay in B-Stock.
Thanks.
Thanks.
Last edited by Imp; 08-22-2005 at 09:37 AM.
#17
Originally Posted by pcimino
Great info...
Okay, so now B Stock states 2 adjustments allowed on a shock (I assume compression and rebound adjustments). But searching for upgrades I keep seeing things like 16 way or 40 way adjustable??? Are these just settings on the dial selector for the damper and they're just saying you can fine tune the stiffness? I see stuff like the dial selector adjusts both rebound and compression. Do I care? Or do I want truly dual adjustable?
Okay, so now B Stock states 2 adjustments allowed on a shock (I assume compression and rebound adjustments). But searching for upgrades I keep seeing things like 16 way or 40 way adjustable??? Are these just settings on the dial selector for the damper and they're just saying you can fine tune the stiffness? I see stuff like the dial selector adjusts both rebound and compression. Do I care? Or do I want truly dual adjustable?
The multi way shocks that you're talking about offer XX number of fixed settings that probably affect both rebound and bounce simultaneously through a single adjustment. That's fine for the street ricer crowd, but not what you really want for autocrossing. IMO, you're better off with a single adjustable, like the Koni, than one of those mult ways becuase you'll only be able to make changes that you want to make. When something is fixed and you can't change it, you can't make it worse. Play with the rebound to your heart's content, but you won't screw it up through changing the bounce in a way that you shouldn't or don't want to just to get the rebound that you do want.
The JIC Coilovers look great but are these B Stock legal.
What else is available? Everyone talks about the Konis, my concern there is I don't want to remove them to adjust the rears. Does Tokico have a setup for the RX-8 yet?
What brands have kits for the Rx-8? Pros, cons? And remember I want to stay in B-Stock.
What brands have kits for the Rx-8? Pros, cons? And remember I want to stay in B-Stock.
![Wink](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/wink.gif)
![Dunno](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/dunno.gif)
You can get Koni 28 series, which are a lot more money for what is probably very little improvement (aside from the convenience of having external adjustments for rebound and bounce on the bottom of the shock). And I think there's an uberexpensive Penske option as well.
The off the shelf single adjustable Koni Sports are pretty cheap and do a really good job. They can be converted so the rears are externally adjustable, but you still have to drop the shock down a bit to get to the adjustment tab and you can also add bump adjustments to them. By the time you do that, you'll probably have about doubled the cost of each shock. More importantly, though, just because you have adjustments available to you doesn't mean that you know how to use them effectively.
Until your driving gets to a level where you are very consistent and your feel has developed enough to tell the difference in what the settings are doing to the car, the extra adjustments probably aren't going to be very helpful for you (unless you stumble onto the perfect combination by accident...but even then, you'll probably change it). Having more adjustments available to you makes it really easy to go chasing settings when you should be focusing on your driving. The less you have to futz with, the easier it is to just drive, and that's where the biggest improvements to your times will come from.
For right now, I'd suggest single adjustable Konis and then ask us for baseline setting suggestions after September 16.
![Wink](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/wink.gif)
(Imp wrote faster than I did. :p)
#19
Originally Posted by Imp
You could always get some custom setup (like clydes Double adjustables) but I feel the OTS konis are about 90% there for an RX8. (I'd change a few things after a few events on them, but they're damn good).
![Wink](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/wink.gif)
#20
What's next?
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: SE Mass
Posts: 1,087
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by clyde
(Imp wrote faster than I did. :p)
--kC
#21
write a few words here, take a phone call, a few words there, chat with someone that drops by my office, a few more words...start all over again, repeat several times...it adds up.
But yes...I have been that slow lately
which is why I took a Challenge school this weekend. I may not be any faster next time out, but I have a clearer idea of what I have to work on now. Oh, and FWIW, apparently Sammy is more scared of the RX-8s now after having driven mine.
But yes...I have been that slow lately
![Frown](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/frown.gif)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post