NASA Track Day- Road Atlanta-Aug. 13 & 14
#76
Go Speed Racer, Go!
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Chattanooga, TN
Posts: 1,778
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by valpac
Sorry, thats not exactly true. It's not the ball joint that has the problem, its the socket in the control arm. You would probably never "feel" anything going wrong until it was too late.
Catastrophic failures sometimes give no warning at all. Material cracking can hardly be seen with the naked eye. NDI (Non-destructive inspections) are needed to accuratley assess impending material failures. And if you CAN see the cracks, count your blessings because failure is usually imminent.
Catastrophic failures sometimes give no warning at all. Material cracking can hardly be seen with the naked eye. NDI (Non-destructive inspections) are needed to accuratley assess impending material failures. And if you CAN see the cracks, count your blessings because failure is usually imminent.
Point taken. Let me rephrase......I'd run it like I stole the time and car, BUT it's your call.....maybe you can get on it quickly and get the recall done asap and still run it. Should you choose not to run, we'd love to have you come work the event.
#78
Ahead of its time
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: GA
Posts: 1,508
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Phlash
..maybe you can get on it quickly and get the recall done asap...
#79
Go Speed Racer, Go!
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Chattanooga, TN
Posts: 1,778
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by valpac
Personally, I would go to the dealer (kinda freaked a little) and see what they would do. I might even pay for the swap outta pocket and hope Mazda re-imburses when the official recall is issued.
Remember, you can also change to a later NASA event. Just call or email Julie and let her know. She'll get ya moved.....
#80
Smooth Criminal
Thread Starter
hey phlash, which jim ellis is that, the on in marietta, or the one in chamblee? i plan on calling on august 1, pleading, and begging. i am not too proud to stoop that low. i really want to run RA with no crashing thoughts in the back of my head.
#81
Registered
iTrader: (3)
Please guys--you know i like to track BUT if you have a ball joint car DO NOT PUT IT ON THE TRACK UNTIL YOU HAVE THE RECALL DONE> Please! There will be other track days--but when you are on the track you never know when you may hit an apron (especially turn 5 and the esses) or even have a spin out.Dont take this type of chance. Plus what person is going to sign your inspection slip knowing this is an issue? If you dont care about yourself then think of the guy that may be following you when you loose your steering. Plus if we are in fact a car club we as a group owe it to ourselves to encourage the recall before tracking. I know the chance of something happening is very small but -- hey---dont take this chance.
olddragger
olddragger
#82
Momentum Keeps Me Going
I'm sorry I don't understand the hesteria about this recall...
1) How many ball joints have we heard ever fail in real life use - ZERO
2) How many people have crashed their 8 due to catastrophic failure of the steering because of this - ZERO
3) A week or so ago we didn't know of this and people were fine going to the track - the ONLY thing that is different is we now have been told there is the possibility of a failure.
It's not like a time bomb that goes off after a certain time now that we are made aware of this. If there is a problem, there has been a problem since day one.
MNAO has a responsibility to recall or they would be in deep trouble if only ONE of the 46 odd thousand of these cars has this problem. So therefore the recall, and good for them and us. But life doesn't stop because of this ... at least not IMO as there have been no reported failures in use, only apparently as I understand in 2 pre-delivery vehicles.
OK so tell me where I'm wrong here please. Life is full of calculated risk...this being one of them. So far the odds look fairly good it would seem. Thanks.
1) How many ball joints have we heard ever fail in real life use - ZERO
2) How many people have crashed their 8 due to catastrophic failure of the steering because of this - ZERO
3) A week or so ago we didn't know of this and people were fine going to the track - the ONLY thing that is different is we now have been told there is the possibility of a failure.
It's not like a time bomb that goes off after a certain time now that we are made aware of this. If there is a problem, there has been a problem since day one.
MNAO has a responsibility to recall or they would be in deep trouble if only ONE of the 46 odd thousand of these cars has this problem. So therefore the recall, and good for them and us. But life doesn't stop because of this ... at least not IMO as there have been no reported failures in use, only apparently as I understand in 2 pre-delivery vehicles.
OK so tell me where I'm wrong here please. Life is full of calculated risk...this being one of them. So far the odds look fairly good it would seem. Thanks.
Last edited by Spin9k; 07-23-2005 at 08:20 PM.
#83
Ahead of its time
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: GA
Posts: 1,508
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Spin9k
I'm sorry I don't understand the hesteria about this recall...
1) How many ball joints have we heard ever fail in real life use - ZERO
2) How many people have crashed their 8 due to catastrophic failure of the steering because of this - ZERO
3) A week or so ago we didn't know of this and people were fine going to the track - the ONLY thing that is different is we now have been told there is the possibility of a failure.
It's not like a time bomb that goes off after a certain time now that we are made aware of this. If there is a problem, there has been a problem since day one.
MNAO has a responsibility to recall or they would be in deep trouble if only ONE of the 46 odd thousand of these cars has this problem. So therefore the recall, and good for them and us. But life doesn't stop because of this ... at least not IMO as there have been no reported failures in use, only apparently as I understand in 2 pre-delivery vehicles.
OK so tell me where I'm wrong here please. Life is full of calculated risk...this being one of them. So far the odds look fairly good it would seem. Thanks.
1) How many ball joints have we heard ever fail in real life use - ZERO
2) How many people have crashed their 8 due to catastrophic failure of the steering because of this - ZERO
3) A week or so ago we didn't know of this and people were fine going to the track - the ONLY thing that is different is we now have been told there is the possibility of a failure.
It's not like a time bomb that goes off after a certain time now that we are made aware of this. If there is a problem, there has been a problem since day one.
MNAO has a responsibility to recall or they would be in deep trouble if only ONE of the 46 odd thousand of these cars has this problem. So therefore the recall, and good for them and us. But life doesn't stop because of this ... at least not IMO as there have been no reported failures in use, only apparently as I understand in 2 pre-delivery vehicles.
OK so tell me where I'm wrong here please. Life is full of calculated risk...this being one of them. So far the odds look fairly good it would seem. Thanks.
BTW, where did you get your data you cited in points 1 & 2? I will take the word of the engineers at MAZDA and manufacturers over mere consumers who really dont know the full impact of this recall.
AND its EXACTLY like a time bomb, except, you dont know what the timer is set for.
And finally, how would you feel if you encouraged a friend to go tracking and they hurt themselves or someone else?
#84
Ahead of its time
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: GA
Posts: 1,508
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by olddragger
Please guys--you know i like to track BUT if you have a ball joint car DO NOT PUT IT ON THE TRACK UNTIL YOU HAVE THE RECALL DONE> Please! There will be other track days
#85
M0D Squad -charter member
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Alabama
Posts: 1,498
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I concur with OD on this -- let's err on the safe side. Supposedly there have been (2) known instances in the U.S., which is a miniscule percentage.
Let's keep it that way.......not worth the risk.
Let's keep it that way.......not worth the risk.
#86
Momentum Keeps Me Going
valpac there are different objective ways at looking at a situation. I've noted you are very vocal in several threads related to this. I did not say that what you are doing is yelling 'the sky is falling, the sky is falling" did I? Not at all! I simply said that I think the hysteria some are expressing is beyond the scope of the problem as it has been presented. You may think differently. I'm OK with that. Just accept that others have other opinions. That's what the forum is for - expressing opinions.
BTW thanks for telling me your opinion that everything I said earlier was wrong, save one thing.
But on topic, nothing wrong with being cautious - erring on the side of caution is fine by me. I'm not encouraging anyone to do anything. Nothing of the sort. And if you don't want to track - great. Each of us has who do has to make that determination based on how they view the facts and the circumstances of the situation.
And to clarify - I have no facts about this other than what we all have read - do you have any other knowledge of the subject yourself? If not, I don't see why your opinions are any more valid than mine.
BTW thanks for telling me your opinion that everything I said earlier was wrong, save one thing.
But on topic, nothing wrong with being cautious - erring on the side of caution is fine by me. I'm not encouraging anyone to do anything. Nothing of the sort. And if you don't want to track - great. Each of us has who do has to make that determination based on how they view the facts and the circumstances of the situation.
And to clarify - I have no facts about this other than what we all have read - do you have any other knowledge of the subject yourself? If not, I don't see why your opinions are any more valid than mine.
#87
Ahead of its time
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: GA
Posts: 1,508
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Spin9k
...do you have any other knowledge of the subject yourself?..
BTW, Spin, are you running the event at RA in Aug? What is you motive for posting in this thread?
Last edited by valpac; 07-24-2005 at 07:39 AM.
#88
Momentum Keeps Me Going
Originally Posted by valpac
only that I am an Aerospace engineer and know a few things about aluminum forgings. Does that qualify me to speak on the subject?
BTW, Spin, are you running the event at RA in Aug? What is you motive for posting in this thread?
BTW, Spin, are you running the event at RA in Aug? What is you motive for posting in this thread?
#90
Registered
iTrader: (3)
my faith in humanity has been restored!
Hey Spin, you are right in a way. Everyone does have their own opinion based on their on experiences and judgement. We respect all. In the end it is the individuals decision. I hope it is the right one. We fuss on this forum I believe, because we are like family in a way, and a healthy family will have differances of opinion. Thats good. Just never lose the respect. (I dont think anyone has.)
Hey Valpac,rxeightr and others thanks for the backup. And I agree we are not hysterical only cautious. By the way I am still driving my 8 every day. AND I will be back in HPDE this fall and winter. Too damn hot at present!
Olddragger
Hey Spin, you are right in a way. Everyone does have their own opinion based on their on experiences and judgement. We respect all. In the end it is the individuals decision. I hope it is the right one. We fuss on this forum I believe, because we are like family in a way, and a healthy family will have differances of opinion. Thats good. Just never lose the respect. (I dont think anyone has.)
Hey Valpac,rxeightr and others thanks for the backup. And I agree we are not hysterical only cautious. By the way I am still driving my 8 every day. AND I will be back in HPDE this fall and winter. Too damn hot at present!
Olddragger
#91
Smooth Criminal
Thread Starter
I too will be erring on the cautious side, I have said it before, I like my car the way it looks right now, not balled up in the wall at RoadAtlanta. I can cancel one week prior to the event, or just transfer the entry. So if one of the Mazda dealers around here will not help me out, then I will not be driving. And it will burn me up. But a known risk, is one I may not be willing to take. Call me chicken, or hysterical, or whatever, I don't care. I want my first track day to be a good one, not one filled with thoughts of bad ball joints.
I am going to call a couple of local dealers tomorrow, if I get any help from them, i will be sure to pass that on here in this thread.
I am going to call a couple of local dealers tomorrow, if I get any help from them, i will be sure to pass that on here in this thread.
#92
Go Speed Racer, Go!
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Chattanooga, TN
Posts: 1,778
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by trhoads
hey phlash, which jim ellis is that, the on in marietta, or the one in chamblee? i plan on calling on august 1, pleading, and begging. i am not too proud to stoop that low. i really want to run RA with no crashing thoughts in the back of my head.
#93
Smooth Criminal
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by Phlash
Marietta....down the street from Charlie's place.
#94
Ahead of its time
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: GA
Posts: 1,508
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by trhoads
thanks, i am going to give them a call soon, to see if they are aware of the issue, and if they would be willing to help me out.
#95
Smooth Criminal
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by valpac
They are aware (sort of). Good luck with them helping. Lemme know what you find out.
Originally Posted by nabil
My car is in there today for some warrantee stuff. I asked them about it and they knew nothing yet.
#96
Go Speed Racer, Go!
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Chattanooga, TN
Posts: 1,778
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
**Calling all Cars**
We need workers for RA.....those that aren't running, please come on down and join us. Worker time creates tracktime credit! For every two weekend events worked, you get one weekend of free tracktime.
From Tom Henning:
Hi Y'all,
The NASA-SE track event at Road Atlanta is right around the corner on August 13 & 14. We need lot of help in all areas from pit & grid to corner flaggers to timing and scoring to race control.
Most of you have worked at a NASA-SE event before and I hope you enjoyed it. Some of you already have assignments, and we hope you will confirm you attendance by registering on line as a worker. That way you will be sure to get credit for working.
We are expecting a large turnout of students and racers so we need all the help we can get. We also hope to continue training of corner flaggers with the professional crew that we have at RA.
On Friday night, we will need help controlling the paddock area and directing the participants to the correct paddock spaces as well under the expert guidance of Jim Mayer, NASA-SE Director.
Please let me know if you plan to attend, when you will arrive and you desires for worker assignment.
Thanks,
Tom Hennig
Race Director, NASA-SE
704-436-6194
704-305-3778 cel
Get your friends involved as well. The more help we have, the safer the track and event is for all.
Gordon
We need workers for RA.....those that aren't running, please come on down and join us. Worker time creates tracktime credit! For every two weekend events worked, you get one weekend of free tracktime.
From Tom Henning:
Hi Y'all,
The NASA-SE track event at Road Atlanta is right around the corner on August 13 & 14. We need lot of help in all areas from pit & grid to corner flaggers to timing and scoring to race control.
Most of you have worked at a NASA-SE event before and I hope you enjoyed it. Some of you already have assignments, and we hope you will confirm you attendance by registering on line as a worker. That way you will be sure to get credit for working.
We are expecting a large turnout of students and racers so we need all the help we can get. We also hope to continue training of corner flaggers with the professional crew that we have at RA.
On Friday night, we will need help controlling the paddock area and directing the participants to the correct paddock spaces as well under the expert guidance of Jim Mayer, NASA-SE Director.
Please let me know if you plan to attend, when you will arrive and you desires for worker assignment.
Thanks,
Tom Hennig
Race Director, NASA-SE
704-436-6194
704-305-3778 cel
Get your friends involved as well. The more help we have, the safer the track and event is for all.
Gordon
Last edited by Phlash; 07-26-2005 at 06:03 AM.
#97
Go Speed Racer, Go!
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Chattanooga, TN
Posts: 1,778
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by trhoads
So hotel Phlash now includes:
-Phlash
-Nabil
-olddragger
-trhoads
-valpac
-legokcen
Should be fun.
-Phlash
-Nabil
-olddragger
-trhoads
-valpac
-legokcen
Should be fun.
Those of you working the event, please register on the NASA website soon so that we can get a good worker headcount....thanks
#98
Smooth Criminal
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by trhoads
then i feel better about doing the event. i have been looking forward to it for months. so i am still in, and will still need a place to crash at hotel phlash.
already let you know, have some coffee.
#99
Smooth Criminal
Thread Starter
I have just about decided to run this event no matter what. I was going to drive before teh recall info came out, and I think I am going to drive now. I am going to do the Autocross theweek before, and see how it goes.
I am still going to beg and plead with the dealers to see if they will do the work before hand. :D
EDIT:
i just spoke with the service department at Rick Case, and they are supposed to get the instructions for the lower control arm fix around August 1 or 2. Once he gets the instructions, I can bring the car in. I explained the situation, and they seemed to be willing to work with me. They already have the instructions on the fuel tank/reflash issue. So I should be able to get both done at the same time.
Just thought I would share that.
I am still going to beg and plead with the dealers to see if they will do the work before hand. :D
EDIT:
i just spoke with the service department at Rick Case, and they are supposed to get the instructions for the lower control arm fix around August 1 or 2. Once he gets the instructions, I can bring the car in. I explained the situation, and they seemed to be willing to work with me. They already have the instructions on the fuel tank/reflash issue. So I should be able to get both done at the same time.
Just thought I would share that.
Last edited by trhoads; 07-26-2005 at 11:22 AM.
#100
Go Speed Racer, Go!
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Chattanooga, TN
Posts: 1,778
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Nabil
I am signed up to work the event. At this point I may just drive in every morning as I want a hot shower after sweating it out all day long.