Cooling Choices - Most Bang for Buck?
#51
I had forgotten about the foam MM---good advice.
We respectively disagree about the secondary radiator and thats cool. My secondary radiator is approx 2 feet from my oem radiator and once again I will challange anyone on its effectiveness in lowering coolant temps over any other single cooling mod. If it is a "preheater" doesnt that mean its working well?
I also disagree on the blockage behind the radiator but lets just leave it at that
what % of angle change in airflow do you think iis occuring?
I didnt know the Cobb unit was released 3 months after the RB flash was released? Dang--i probably would have gotten one if I had known then. Learn something everyday. I just remember it didnt solve tenp issues--it did help a little.
Hasnt 230F shown to cause damage if allowed to happen frequently or for a long period of time? Narrow window is absoulutely right.
Lets not debate oil on this thread OK. I just added it as an addentum tipe hint to the op's oridginal ?
Good input.
olddragger
We respectively disagree about the secondary radiator and thats cool. My secondary radiator is approx 2 feet from my oem radiator and once again I will challange anyone on its effectiveness in lowering coolant temps over any other single cooling mod. If it is a "preheater" doesnt that mean its working well?
I also disagree on the blockage behind the radiator but lets just leave it at that
what % of angle change in airflow do you think iis occuring?
I didnt know the Cobb unit was released 3 months after the RB flash was released? Dang--i probably would have gotten one if I had known then. Learn something everyday. I just remember it didnt solve tenp issues--it did help a little.
Hasnt 230F shown to cause damage if allowed to happen frequently or for a long period of time? Narrow window is absoulutely right.
Lets not debate oil on this thread OK. I just added it as an addentum tipe hint to the op's oridginal ?
Good input.
olddragger
#52
Is this damage potential due to the limitations of water or ethylene glycol & water or is this due to some other issue such as loss of oil viscosity or excessive thermal expansion? I'm asking because I know some folks on the boards here are using Evans waterless coolants (Assuming nothing goes wrong, I will be one of them by the end of the week) which maintains a much higher boiling point than pressurized water or pressurized ethylene glycol and water. It occurs to me that at 230F average coolant temperature, water or ethylene glycol and water should be experiencing localised boiling at the hottest points of the engine, putting thermal and mechanical stress on various areas such as the exhaust passage coolant seals. This was one of the reasons that I chose to make the conversion.
#53
Registered User
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 3,086
Likes: 1
From: Misinformation Director - Evolv Chicago
I'm trying to decide which cooling mod or mods to do to my 04 RX8. I've got over 65k on the clock and I'm going to be taking a lot of road trips for work soon. I am worried about the increased heat of playing on the highway for long periods of time.
I was thinking of one of two of the following mods:
Beatrush Under Panel ($180)
RaceRoot's Oil Cooler Fans (Driver/Passenger/BOTH sides) ($195/$390)
RaceRoot's AC Fan Control Unit ($135)
Re-Medy Water Pump/T-Stat Combo ($300)
BHR's Radiator ($550)
Now I am kinda strapped for cash ATM, but which mod/mods would give me the most cooling for the cost?
Any input is appreciated.
I was thinking of one of two of the following mods:
Beatrush Under Panel ($180)
RaceRoot's Oil Cooler Fans (Driver/Passenger/BOTH sides) ($195/$390)
RaceRoot's AC Fan Control Unit ($135)
Re-Medy Water Pump/T-Stat Combo ($300)
BHR's Radiator ($550)
Now I am kinda strapped for cash ATM, but which mod/mods would give me the most cooling for the cost?
Any input is appreciated.
It also is Fall and you live in PA, according to your sig. Unless you are leaving the northeast the cold weather will only benefit your cooling system. Also, most of highway driving is low load + high speed = good cooling. Some bursts at high load here and there should not be a problem.
Bottom line, I just don't see anything to indicate you have to spend money because you *might* have cooling issues.
Save your money, watch your AP, and add mods if your temps are consistently high.
As for mods, 3 best we've experienced at the race track:
-Mazmart Water Pump
-70/30 Water coolant mix
-auxiliary rad mounted like a FMIC, or on a modified undertray like Pettit
Everything else wasn't even close in effectiveness.
Last edited by Red Devil; 10-13-2009 at 01:43 PM.
#56
The whole stack twists and changes shape as it overheats because of the different rates of thermal expansion possessed by the iron and aluminum.
#57
Originally Posted by olddragger
Hasnt 230F shown to cause damage if allowed to happen frequently or for a long period of time?
That's why I say that changing the fan control temperatures will have the largest marginal benefit for most cars out there. If you trigger the fans to turn faster at a lower temperature, the motor will hardly ever see 220 or 230. And yet it can already handle those temps continuously.
#58
Even though I wouldn't ever encourage anyone to run their car that hot, Mazda has been doing it since at least 1992 when they switched to electric fans for the FD. Does it do damage? Well I'm sure it doesn't help the coolant seals in the long run, and all that heat may contribute to the sparkplug area cracks that are sometimes found on rotor housings in higher mileage engines.
That's why I say that changing the fan control temperatures will have the largest marginal benefit for most cars out there. If you trigger the fans to turn faster at a lower temperature, the motor will hardly ever see 220 or 230. And yet it can already handle those temps continuously.
That's why I say that changing the fan control temperatures will have the largest marginal benefit for most cars out there. If you trigger the fans to turn faster at a lower temperature, the motor will hardly ever see 220 or 230. And yet it can already handle those temps continuously.
For my own purposes, I decided to follow in TeamRX8's footsteps and use Evans waterless coolant. At ambient pressure, it gives me a 370F boiling point and the -79F freezing point is low enough for my purposes. In fairness, I had seen the Evans coolant used two decades ago in boingers running 16:1 compression in racing conditions with coolant temperatures that none of us would even consider in SCCA GT-class racing. I do realise that our engines have very different mechanical stresses from thermal expansion than boingers do, which is why I am not planning on running as high temperatures as they were racing with; but I am interested in improving the engine's efficiency without breaking it.
I know this means I am trying something different, and it might bite me in the keister for my trouble; but I've waited two decades (I was driving an FB back then) to try this in a rotary.
Evans IROC-Z '89 Camaro
Evans Cooling Systems, Inc. (formerly Mecca Development) Built, Owned, & Operated SCCA GT-1 / Trans-AM, NPG Development Car. The 335ci V8 ran a compression ratio of 16:1 and was - on every race - pushed to ever higher levels of performance, accumulating record after record for fast laps, pole positions and wins.
Evans Cooling Systems, Inc. (formerly Mecca Development) Built, Owned, & Operated SCCA GT-1 / Trans-AM, NPG Development Car. The 335ci V8 ran a compression ratio of 16:1 and was - on every race - pushed to ever higher levels of performance, accumulating record after record for fast laps, pole positions and wins.
Last edited by longpath; 10-16-2009 at 09:16 AM. Reason: apparent I suck at typing and I misremembered the compression ratio on Evans' GT class racer from 20 years ago
#59
additional cooling passage modifications are done in the leading sparkplug area (also in the exhaust port area) using that exact line of thought. Evans? Hmmm--never thought about that in relation to this--but I do see the lodgic invloved. Plus if you keep the temps below 230 wouldnt that even be better? Evans is it a pita to do and maintain?
OD
OD
#60
additional cooling passage modifications are done in the leading sparkplug area (also in the exhaust port area) using that exact line of thought. Evans? Hmmm--never thought about that in relation to this--but I do see the lodgic invloved. Plus if you keep the temps below 230 wouldnt that even be better? Evans is it a pita to do and maintain?
OD
OD
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
GranTouTou
Series I Wheels, Tires, Brakes & Suspension
0
09-30-2015 07:11 AM