Should I pay for a compression test or not?
#1
Should I pay for a compression test or not?
Here's the story. I have an '04 MT with 43,xxx miles. I have had some minor(?) warm starting issues since I got it. A couple weekends ago I replaced my coils, plugs, and wires. Nothing changed as far as the warm starts. I was at the dealer earlier this week and I told the service guy about the problem and that I replaced those parts and nothing changed. He asked me about my shutoff procedure and I told him if it's up to temp I just shut it off. But if not then I rev to 3K, hold for 10-12 seconds, and turn the key off as it's reving down.
Get this, he told me that I should be doing the rev procedure EVERY time I shut it off! I looked at him stupid and said "that's the first time I've heard that, and that's pretty embarrassing don't ya think?" He just told me to try it and see if it helped.
Here's my dilema, the car has always started on the first crank and it's never cranked over 4-5 seconds, it's not that bad but to me it's still longer than a 6 yr old car should take to start. I would like to hear from the guys that have failed a compression test, do you think my car will fail? I know Mazda makes you replace the coils, plugs, and wires before they will test it, so should I pay for the test now while it's all fresh or should I wait till the problem gets worse and have to do another tuneup?
What do ya think??
Get this, he told me that I should be doing the rev procedure EVERY time I shut it off! I looked at him stupid and said "that's the first time I've heard that, and that's pretty embarrassing don't ya think?" He just told me to try it and see if it helped.
Here's my dilema, the car has always started on the first crank and it's never cranked over 4-5 seconds, it's not that bad but to me it's still longer than a 6 yr old car should take to start. I would like to hear from the guys that have failed a compression test, do you think my car will fail? I know Mazda makes you replace the coils, plugs, and wires before they will test it, so should I pay for the test now while it's all fresh or should I wait till the problem gets worse and have to do another tuneup?
What do ya think??
#2
Administrator
iTrader: (7)
go back and tell them you have severe power loss in the car.
your engine is still under warranty
http://www.finishlineperformance.com...4-08-1924g.pdf
your engine is still under warranty
http://www.finishlineperformance.com...4-08-1924g.pdf
#3
Thanks Jedi.
The car runs strong and the idle has improved with the tuneup. Really my only concern is the longer warm start cranking time. I imagine if I complained about the idle and a loss of power, they would want to take it for a test drive, wouldn't they?
The car runs strong and the idle has improved with the tuneup. Really my only concern is the longer warm start cranking time. I imagine if I complained about the idle and a loss of power, they would want to take it for a test drive, wouldn't they?
#4
Administrator
iTrader: (7)
I'm not telling you to lie but if you were to describe the symptoms in that TSB, I'm sure they'd start running some of those tests.
long warm cranking time is a possible indication of low compression which is why I'm suggesting you take this route (and possibly save the fee for the compression test)
long warm cranking time is a possible indication of low compression which is why I'm suggesting you take this route (and possibly save the fee for the compression test)
#6
Registered
Hate to say it but it's gonna be low compression, the only question is whether it's low enough yet for Mazda to replace it. Was the service guy you were talking to the service manager? If they don't do it, call Mazda and tell them about how this crazy dealer is spreading crazy talk about how their rotary needs to be shut down and you just need to talk to someone who isn't crazy.
#7
Grasshopper
iTrader: (1)
Warm start issues can be caused by low compression, but don't rule out the starter (especially if you have an '04 or '05 and still on the original starter).
I used to have warm start issues too and hated going to the gas pump because I looked like an idiot trying to start the car.
After replacing the starter, I've never had a problem since.
I own my own compression tester and recently performed one and my results were fine, so my warm start issues were not low compression related.
Another member here recently replaced his starter after having warm start issues and it worked out for him too.
Its always nice to know the health of your engine, so you may want to get it tested just to know and get it replaced if needed (or know if you are soon due so you can before the warranty runs out).
I used to have warm start issues too and hated going to the gas pump because I looked like an idiot trying to start the car.
After replacing the starter, I've never had a problem since.
I own my own compression tester and recently performed one and my results were fine, so my warm start issues were not low compression related.
Another member here recently replaced his starter after having warm start issues and it worked out for him too.
Its always nice to know the health of your engine, so you may want to get it tested just to know and get it replaced if needed (or know if you are soon due so you can before the warranty runs out).
#8
Registered
Warm start issues can be caused by low compression, but don't rule out the starter (especially if you have an '04 or '05 and still on the original starter).
I used to have warm start issues too and hated going to the gas pump because I looked like an idiot trying to start the car.
After replacing the starter, I've never had a problem since.
I own my own compression tester and recently performed one and my results were fine, so my warm start issues were not low compression related.
Another member here recently replaced his starter after having warm start issues and it worked out for him too.
Its always nice to know the health of your engine, so you may want to get it tested just to know and get it replaced if needed (or know if you are soon due so you can before the warranty runs out).
I used to have warm start issues too and hated going to the gas pump because I looked like an idiot trying to start the car.
After replacing the starter, I've never had a problem since.
I own my own compression tester and recently performed one and my results were fine, so my warm start issues were not low compression related.
Another member here recently replaced his starter after having warm start issues and it worked out for him too.
Its always nice to know the health of your engine, so you may want to get it tested just to know and get it replaced if needed (or know if you are soon due so you can before the warranty runs out).
#9
Grasshopper
iTrader: (1)
Easily... probably not.
A compression test with my original starter was at 166rpm while my upgraded starter was 248rpm.
So getting a compressing test can tell you both.
You're free to suspect what you want, but I can't completely agree since my warm start issues was not the result of low compression.
Not saying its not possible because it can, but it shouldn't be the only sign used to determine low compression IMO.
A compression test with my original starter was at 166rpm while my upgraded starter was 248rpm.
So getting a compressing test can tell you both.
Not saying its not possible because it can, but it shouldn't be the only sign used to determine low compression IMO.
#10
Registered
Of course not, that's what compression tests are for, a suspicion is just a suspicion, even if it is based on so many engine failures. BTW, how high was your compression?
#14
Administrator
iTrader: (7)
Jon: your comressoin is better then mine but I don't seem to have hot start issues.
it's really weird.
it's really weird.
#15
I asked to see the service records at the dealer a while back, the upgraded starter was installed for the last owner. I just checked Oreillys here in town and they sell a compression tester for around $30, and they also loan them out. I think I'll just borrow thiers first to make sure it will work. I'll do a search to find the compression test procedure. Sounds like a good idea to have a tester around, that way you'd have a good idea where your compression was at before you even take it to the dealer.
#19
Grasshopper
iTrader: (1)
#20
Administrator
iTrader: (7)
Jon: yeah, mine is a late 05 which came with the upgraded starter. My cranking speeds were around 260 rpm when I tested it.
I'm tip toe'ing with that minnimum psi tolerance on my current engine.
drives like a best though, go figure.
I'm tip toe'ing with that minnimum psi tolerance on my current engine.
drives like a best though, go figure.
#21
This is where I bought mine:
http://rotarydiagnostics.com/
http://rotarydiagnostics.com/
Holy Hell, those things are pricey! Takin a trip through Nebraska anytime soon? lol
#22
Registered User
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Gardner, KS
Posts: 333
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Upgrade your starter and swap out your battery. It's more expensive than a compression test through Mazda but IMO it's maintenance anyways. The difference between the old starter and new starter is truly night and day. If you have the original battery that alone could be your problem.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
gwailo
New Member Forum
38
05-14-2024 06:57 AM