Coolant leak?
#1
Thread Starter
Registered
iTrader: (1)
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 1,934
Likes: 0
From: Carolina Beach, NC
Coolant leak?
Hey all, got a little issue going on...figured I get ya'lls perspective.
A little history, '04 MT with 68k, 32k on this motor, maintained to perfection, never flooded, on problem I've had is an ongoing ignition problem. Anyways, a few months ago I noticed a coolant puddle under the car and did a little investigating and noticed some coolant on the rear housing and all over the oil pan. I took it into the dealership and there we found a failed hose clamp on the water pump. Replaced clamp and all was well, sorta.
I have now swapped out my coolant since the temps have gotten colder. I run 25% coolant, distilled water and water wetter during the summer and have now replaced it all with Prestone 50/50. Problem is the past few times I have checked my coolant level it has been well below the cold line. I have refilled the coolant tank everytime (6 times now) and it still falls below the full line. I can't find any external leaks and I haven't noticed any white smoke from my exhaust either.
I'm at a loss, atleast in our race cars when the motor starts buring coolant we can usually attribute it to a coolant seal gone bad. I had a feeling this motor was failing due to my last compression check compared to the one I had done back in Feb. In Feb, on the Mazda tester I was running 9.8's and higher on all rotor faces and on the last test my numbers were all in the low 8's. The dealership said the numbers were still within the norm but for compression to drop that much and now that I seem to be losing coolant, I don't know.
How much coolant have you all been adding? I've gone through almost 2 gallons in the last 6 months. I'm sure that's not normal...
-Nic
A little history, '04 MT with 68k, 32k on this motor, maintained to perfection, never flooded, on problem I've had is an ongoing ignition problem. Anyways, a few months ago I noticed a coolant puddle under the car and did a little investigating and noticed some coolant on the rear housing and all over the oil pan. I took it into the dealership and there we found a failed hose clamp on the water pump. Replaced clamp and all was well, sorta.
I have now swapped out my coolant since the temps have gotten colder. I run 25% coolant, distilled water and water wetter during the summer and have now replaced it all with Prestone 50/50. Problem is the past few times I have checked my coolant level it has been well below the cold line. I have refilled the coolant tank everytime (6 times now) and it still falls below the full line. I can't find any external leaks and I haven't noticed any white smoke from my exhaust either.
I'm at a loss, atleast in our race cars when the motor starts buring coolant we can usually attribute it to a coolant seal gone bad. I had a feeling this motor was failing due to my last compression check compared to the one I had done back in Feb. In Feb, on the Mazda tester I was running 9.8's and higher on all rotor faces and on the last test my numbers were all in the low 8's. The dealership said the numbers were still within the norm but for compression to drop that much and now that I seem to be losing coolant, I don't know.
How much coolant have you all been adding? I've gone through almost 2 gallons in the last 6 months. I'm sure that's not normal...
-Nic
#4
Thread Starter
Registered
iTrader: (1)
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 1,934
Likes: 0
From: Carolina Beach, NC
I just had it on jack stands this past weekend and didn't notice anything. I even took it out and drove it pretty hard to build up some pressure in the system still didn't notice any leaks. Now I haven't noticed any smoke coming out of the exhaust but when our race cars were burning coolant you would only notice it on the track during the up and down shifts...I haven't had anyone tail me to see if that holds true in this case.
#7
Try this from: http://www.aa1car.com/library/coolant_leaks.htm
PRESSURE TESTING THE COOLING SYSTEM
There are several ways to find out whether or not your cooling system is holding pressure. One is to top off your cooling system, tighten the radiator cap and start the engine. When the engine reaches normal operating temperature, turn on the air conditioner (to increase the cooling load on the system) and/or take it for a short drive. Then check the radiator, hoses and water pump for seepage or leaks.
WARNING: DO NOT open the radiator cap while the engine is hot! Even if the cooling system is leaking, the coolant will be under considerable pressure -- especially if it is low and coolant is boiling inside the engine. Shut the engine off and let it sit about an hour so it can cool down. Then place a rag over the radiator cap and slowly turn the cap until it starts to release pressure. Wait until all the pressure has vented before turning the cap the rest of the way off.
A special tool called a pressure tester can also be used to check your cooling system. The tool is nothing more than a little hand pump with a combination vacuum-pressure gauge and a fitting that is attached to the radiator filler neck. To check for leaks, attach the tool to the radiator and pressurize the radiator to the pressure rating on the radiator cap. For example, if you have a radiator cap that says 12 pounds, you pressurize the radiator to 12 lbs. and wait to see what happens. If there are no leaks, the system should hold pressure for 10 to 15 minutes. If it does not hold pressure, the system is leaking. If you cannot see any visible leaks on the outside, it means the leak is inside (bad head gasket or cracked head or block).
Leak detection dye can also be added to the coolant to make a slow leak easier to find. Some of these dyes glow bright green or yellow when exposed to ultraviolet light.
PRESSURE TESTING THE COOLING SYSTEM
There are several ways to find out whether or not your cooling system is holding pressure. One is to top off your cooling system, tighten the radiator cap and start the engine. When the engine reaches normal operating temperature, turn on the air conditioner (to increase the cooling load on the system) and/or take it for a short drive. Then check the radiator, hoses and water pump for seepage or leaks.
WARNING: DO NOT open the radiator cap while the engine is hot! Even if the cooling system is leaking, the coolant will be under considerable pressure -- especially if it is low and coolant is boiling inside the engine. Shut the engine off and let it sit about an hour so it can cool down. Then place a rag over the radiator cap and slowly turn the cap until it starts to release pressure. Wait until all the pressure has vented before turning the cap the rest of the way off.
A special tool called a pressure tester can also be used to check your cooling system. The tool is nothing more than a little hand pump with a combination vacuum-pressure gauge and a fitting that is attached to the radiator filler neck. To check for leaks, attach the tool to the radiator and pressurize the radiator to the pressure rating on the radiator cap. For example, if you have a radiator cap that says 12 pounds, you pressurize the radiator to 12 lbs. and wait to see what happens. If there are no leaks, the system should hold pressure for 10 to 15 minutes. If it does not hold pressure, the system is leaking. If you cannot see any visible leaks on the outside, it means the leak is inside (bad head gasket or cracked head or block).
Leak detection dye can also be added to the coolant to make a slow leak easier to find. Some of these dyes glow bright green or yellow when exposed to ultraviolet light.
#10
if it is a stock 04 motor. it is the h2o pump.. when they took out my motor at 55k miles it was a med weep...
and now with my second motor.. funny i am smelling that smell.. at ~ 50 k miles..
go figure..
beers
and now with my second motor.. funny i am smelling that smell.. at ~ 50 k miles..
go figure..
beers
#11
Thread Starter
Registered
iTrader: (1)
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 1,934
Likes: 0
From: Carolina Beach, NC
Got the motor replaced in Sept '06. I had a coolant hose leaking from the water pump but we replaced a hose clamp and it stopped. I'm thinking about pulling the water pump and rebuilding it to ROAR specs. I've lost a little coolant since Sat when I filled it last...I may try a dye test this weekend.
Last edited by I8U; 11-28-2008 at 10:26 AM.
#13
dye test will be good------oil is ok ---Right? Sure it is as you probably already checked that out.
have you rerouted your overflow hose? put a catch can on it just to be sure it aint getting blown out.
all in all sounds like new engine time with that much compression change.
OD
have you rerouted your overflow hose? put a catch can on it just to be sure it aint getting blown out.
all in all sounds like new engine time with that much compression change.
OD
#14
Thread Starter
Registered
iTrader: (1)
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 1,934
Likes: 0
From: Carolina Beach, NC
Denny, no catch can for me...I have been monitoring the oil but since my dealership neglected the TSB for the "milky" dipstick I really can't be sure if it is coolant mixing in or just the condensation that was originally attributed to the milky dipstick.
When I was originally noticed the loss of coolant I thought most of it came from the bad hose clamp on the water pump the dealership replaced...but I have still lost coolant since then. I mean I checked it just over a month ago and it was fine then I checked it last last Sat and it was definitely below the cold mark.
*edit*
Well, I called the dealership to schedule an appt. They were really rude to me today, I have been a loyal customer of theirs for well over 3 yrs...they told they were gonna charge me a diagnosis fee and that I would no longer be able to receive "goodwill" service anymore. I asked what "goodwill" service I had received, and they responded by telling me it was all the plugs, coils, and wires I had received over the last 30k miles. I was like well, F you for giving me bad plugs and coils and not diagnosing the problem properly in the first place!
I told them to cancel my appt and I will be in once my motor final just blows up! I still have 32k left on the engine warranty so, I will just deal with it. I'm still gonna do a dye test and see if there is an external leak, maybe I'll find something I can fix myself. But still the compression is what has me worried, it really is a big difference from February's test to the one I had done in August...
When I was originally noticed the loss of coolant I thought most of it came from the bad hose clamp on the water pump the dealership replaced...but I have still lost coolant since then. I mean I checked it just over a month ago and it was fine then I checked it last last Sat and it was definitely below the cold mark.
*edit*
Well, I called the dealership to schedule an appt. They were really rude to me today, I have been a loyal customer of theirs for well over 3 yrs...they told they were gonna charge me a diagnosis fee and that I would no longer be able to receive "goodwill" service anymore. I asked what "goodwill" service I had received, and they responded by telling me it was all the plugs, coils, and wires I had received over the last 30k miles. I was like well, F you for giving me bad plugs and coils and not diagnosing the problem properly in the first place!
I told them to cancel my appt and I will be in once my motor final just blows up! I still have 32k left on the engine warranty so, I will just deal with it. I'm still gonna do a dye test and see if there is an external leak, maybe I'll find something I can fix myself. But still the compression is what has me worried, it really is a big difference from February's test to the one I had done in August...
Last edited by I8U; 11-28-2008 at 06:51 PM.
#15
I am lucky I have a good dealer----although i dont use them any much--i always bring donuts.
The dye will tell the story--but like you say ---the compression---?
Sorry you will not be at RA--maybe next time.
OD
The dye will tell the story--but like you say ---the compression---?
Sorry you will not be at RA--maybe next time.
OD
#16
Thread Starter
Registered
iTrader: (1)
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 1,934
Likes: 0
From: Carolina Beach, NC
I always thought I had a good dealer too, they have done well over $15k in warranty on my car...that's easy money for them. I need to find some dye, think AutoZone or Advanced might carry it?
Yeah Denny, I'm sorry I won't be attending the RA event myself. I was gonna be driving a ROAR car too, may be next time.
Yeah Denny, I'm sorry I won't be attending the RA event myself. I was gonna be driving a ROAR car too, may be next time.
#17
I had a similar problem fixed last month, but not quite as bad. My coolant light kept coming on and the level was getting low faster than it should have. I had it checked and the coolant sensor had gone bad in it. They replaced the bottle, which is what contains the sensor. When I drove it after that the light came back on after about 20 miles of driving. Seems there also had been little chew holes in the hose near the overflow. When the coolant got hot it would start leaking out, which would happen only after about 40 miles or more of continuous driving. Well, this time when it became obvious that there was a definite leak I took it back in, which is when they found the chew holes, and the hose and almost completely broken at that point. I got a new hose and don't have that problem anymore.
#18
I hate to steal this post but i have a problem with my coolent too my light keeps coming on when ever im at 3 k rPM and above and when ever the level gets even lower its on regardles of the rpm and i have steam/smoke coming through the air vents on the inside of the car and i cant find a leak under the car. HELP please oh my passenger side is drenched with condensation.
Last edited by fritschep; 03-27-2009 at 11:02 PM.
#19
fritschep,
Sounds like your coolant level sensor which is built into the coolant reservoir may be going bad.
My level sensor went bad to the point where the low coolant light stayed on all the time, then about a month after that, my water pump or water pump gasket failed. I found out the hard way when I saw steam coming from under my car.
The water pump is located just below the alternator. Look carefully around the water pump and see if you can spot coolant seeping around the water pump.
The water pump has two weep holes, one on top and one on the bottom. Take a folded up clean white paper towel, and push it up against the bottom weep hole and see if it's leaking.
What year is you car and how may miles do you have? My 2004 coolant issues started around 57k miles.
Sounds like your coolant level sensor which is built into the coolant reservoir may be going bad.
My level sensor went bad to the point where the low coolant light stayed on all the time, then about a month after that, my water pump or water pump gasket failed. I found out the hard way when I saw steam coming from under my car.
The water pump is located just below the alternator. Look carefully around the water pump and see if you can spot coolant seeping around the water pump.
The water pump has two weep holes, one on top and one on the bottom. Take a folded up clean white paper towel, and push it up against the bottom weep hole and see if it's leaking.
What year is you car and how may miles do you have? My 2004 coolant issues started around 57k miles.
#21
Heater core if its smells like coolant. If it's just water, and you've been running your AC, it could be a blocked drain hose.
Last edited by rx8cited; 03-27-2009 at 11:26 PM.
#22
Heater core if its smells like coolant. If it's just water, and you've been running your AC, it could be a blocked drain hose.
#23
Soak up some of the wetness with a white paper towel. What does it look and smell like? Put some coolant on another paper towel and compare the two.
When you turn on your AC, do you hear the compressor click on?
When you turn on your AC, do you hear the compressor click on?
#24
all i hear are fans when i turn the AC as for the dampness its hard to tell i sorta smells like coolent but then again the whole inside of the car smells like that now this is gonna sound weird but when ever i rev the engine a little it sounds like there is watter under the DASH
Last edited by fritschep; 03-27-2009 at 11:51 PM.
#25
Water under the dash sound seems to indicate air in the coolant system.
1) What's the coolant level in the reservoir? You may need to bleed the coolant system. But if the heater core is leaking, you need to get that fixed first. Do the paper towel test I suggested to see if the dampness is coolant or not.
2) With the car on, fan speed set to 1, heat control **** in the middle, mode set for air thru upper vents only, when you push the AC button from off to on, do you hear the compressor click? If not, sounds like the AC has a problem. Check the A/C fuse, it's #18 - see owner's manual.
1) What's the coolant level in the reservoir? You may need to bleed the coolant system. But if the heater core is leaking, you need to get that fixed first. Do the paper towel test I suggested to see if the dampness is coolant or not.
2) With the car on, fan speed set to 1, heat control **** in the middle, mode set for air thru upper vents only, when you push the AC button from off to on, do you hear the compressor click? If not, sounds like the AC has a problem. Check the A/C fuse, it's #18 - see owner's manual.