Dealer won't fix engine rattle -- They claim it's pinging
#1
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Bellevue, WA
Posts: 134
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dealer won't fix engine rattle -- They claim it's pinging
I drive an '05 MT/GT model with a little over 3K miles on it, and I'm experiencing weird noises at certain RPMs. The noise it makes is noticeable at WOT; it sounds like some sort of metallic vibration. The sound occurs between the following RPM ranges: 6000 and 6250; 7000-7500; and 8000+. I can sometimes it between 3000-4000, but it's very subtle. I started hearing the sound sometime after the break-in period. (The car has had its 1st oil change at 1500 mi.)
I took the car to my dealer for servicing and performed a test drive with one of the mechanics. The mechanic couldn't hear it at first, but later he confirmed the noise (at 6000-6250 rpm) -- I did the driving. Anyhow, when I picked up the car, they didn't fix a thing; they gave me a piece of paper saying that its a "standard sound" for that engine and the cause of it is pinging. (It basically says that lower octane gasoline may cause higher pinging, and they recommend using only 91 octane or higher.)
Since I bought the car, (I'm the first owner) I have ONLY fed my car 92 octane gas from Chevron -- it doesn't get much better than that. Personally, I find their diagnosis to be a load of crap. If it really is pinging, how come I can reproduce the sound EVERYTIME single time? I'm taking the car back in on Thursday to have them check this 'noise' problem again, but I would like to point out a few possibilities to them. (I've installed the REVi intake and ram air since the last visit to the dealer, and I can still repro the sound. I hope they don't point at the intake and say: "Well, I see you've been f***ing around with your car ... that's the problem! Screw you! ... void warranty ... have a nice day!"
I would like to also add that when the car is idle, it also makes a weird noise (kinda like pistons moving -- but wtf?). This only happens when the engine is very warm.
Have any of you had this problem or can someone provide some insight as to where the problem may be? Thanks.
I took the car to my dealer for servicing and performed a test drive with one of the mechanics. The mechanic couldn't hear it at first, but later he confirmed the noise (at 6000-6250 rpm) -- I did the driving. Anyhow, when I picked up the car, they didn't fix a thing; they gave me a piece of paper saying that its a "standard sound" for that engine and the cause of it is pinging. (It basically says that lower octane gasoline may cause higher pinging, and they recommend using only 91 octane or higher.)
Since I bought the car, (I'm the first owner) I have ONLY fed my car 92 octane gas from Chevron -- it doesn't get much better than that. Personally, I find their diagnosis to be a load of crap. If it really is pinging, how come I can reproduce the sound EVERYTIME single time? I'm taking the car back in on Thursday to have them check this 'noise' problem again, but I would like to point out a few possibilities to them. (I've installed the REVi intake and ram air since the last visit to the dealer, and I can still repro the sound. I hope they don't point at the intake and say: "Well, I see you've been f***ing around with your car ... that's the problem! Screw you! ... void warranty ... have a nice day!"
I would like to also add that when the car is idle, it also makes a weird noise (kinda like pistons moving -- but wtf?). This only happens when the engine is very warm.
Have any of you had this problem or can someone provide some insight as to where the problem may be? Thanks.
#3
S-DAIS
https://www.rx8club.com/showpost.php...&postcount=153
And your dealer is a moron. They shouldn't send you home with a pinging engine.
https://www.rx8club.com/showpost.php...&postcount=153
And your dealer is a moron. They shouldn't send you home with a pinging engine.
Last edited by 8is>enuff; 07-27-2005 at 09:54 AM. Reason: whatever
#6
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Bellevue, WA
Posts: 134
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by 8is>enuff
S-DIAS
https://www.rx8club.com/showpost.php...&postcount=153
And your dealer is a moron. They shouldn't send you home with a pinging engine.
https://www.rx8club.com/showpost.php...&postcount=153
And your dealer is a moron. They shouldn't send you home with a pinging engine.
About the dealer... Yeah, I have the same feeling; I don't think my dealer really knows squat about my rotaries. When I brought the car in last time, I told them to update my flash to the latest version. They guy was like: "What? Pauses... Oh yeah, we just got a software update last night. But... wait, how did you know about that?" I told them that I've been reading constantly online and I instantly lost credibility with the guy. What the hell? I understand that the majority of us are somewhat ignorant when it comes to servicing engines, etc. but there are a few people on the forums that really know wtf they are talking about. Also, people share feedback from what dealer mechanics have said in the past -- maybe that's why we sound like morons sometimes? :D Interestingly enough, they still don't know squat about recalls for my car. So how is it that I'm more informed when it's clearly their job to do so?
Last edited by ~)(; 07-27-2005 at 03:37 AM.
#8
Rotary only since 1980
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Southeast of Seattle
Posts: 587
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Which dealer did you take the car to? The general consensus of the NW area is that University Mazda has the most qualified service techs.
Try searching the S-DAIS threads. I recall reading that when the various doors/flaps in the intake are actuated, there is momentary turbulence that results in a slight power dip. I believe that some people reported a noise as well. It may not be the same noise as you are experiencing but the RPMs where you hear is very suspicious.
Try searching the S-DAIS threads. I recall reading that when the various doors/flaps in the intake are actuated, there is momentary turbulence that results in a slight power dip. I believe that some people reported a noise as well. It may not be the same noise as you are experiencing but the RPMs where you hear is very suspicious.
#9
It could just be a rattle.
My Mazda3s made a very similar sounding noise (judging by your description) and it was 100% reproducable over 75% throttle at very specific RPM points to varying levels of volume. Turns out is was a problem with the muffler. At certain frequencies it would resonate just so and create a odd metallic vibrating noise. The replaced the entire exhaust system and no more sound.
I could have swore up and down it was the transmission or something on the drivetrain at least. It sounded like it was coming from right under the center console. But I wasn't even close.
My Mazda3s made a very similar sounding noise (judging by your description) and it was 100% reproducable over 75% throttle at very specific RPM points to varying levels of volume. Turns out is was a problem with the muffler. At certain frequencies it would resonate just so and create a odd metallic vibrating noise. The replaced the entire exhaust system and no more sound.
I could have swore up and down it was the transmission or something on the drivetrain at least. It sounded like it was coming from right under the center console. But I wasn't even close.
#10
there is NOTHING wrong with your car...and it is NOT pinging
this sound is normal and is a certain 'tone' that occurs at hi-revs...all of the MTs do this...it is a sweet sound :D
as for the piston sounding noise...if u have the AC on u will definitely hear it more often and louder...just the engine keeping the rpms up for A/C functioning
Don't worry
but yes your dealer is an idiot...they shouldn't have told u it was pinging...no worries :D
as for the Revi...keep it, once I have time in a week or so I'll install one myself :D
this sound is normal and is a certain 'tone' that occurs at hi-revs...all of the MTs do this...it is a sweet sound :D
as for the piston sounding noise...if u have the AC on u will definitely hear it more often and louder...just the engine keeping the rpms up for A/C functioning
Don't worry
but yes your dealer is an idiot...they shouldn't have told u it was pinging...no worries :D
as for the Revi...keep it, once I have time in a week or so I'll install one myself :D
#11
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Bellevue, WA
Posts: 134
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Blue87Sport
Which dealer did you take the car to? The general consensus of the NW area is that University Mazda has the most qualified service techs.
Try searching the S-DAIS threads. I recall reading that when the various doors/flaps in the intake are actuated, there is momentary turbulence that results in a slight power dip. I believe that some people reported a noise as well. It may not be the same noise as you are experiencing but the RPMs where you hear is very suspicious.
Try searching the S-DAIS threads. I recall reading that when the various doors/flaps in the intake are actuated, there is momentary turbulence that results in a slight power dip. I believe that some people reported a noise as well. It may not be the same noise as you are experiencing but the RPMs where you hear is very suspicious.
I don't know why I bought the extended warranty from them -- maybe b/c it was fairly cheap and I knew I was going to be beating this car worse than any of my previous cars. However, I've taken an interest in mechanics recently and I somewhat feel that I can do just about anything to the car as long as I have the workshop manual(s), necessary tools, time, and of course this forum. I'm thinking about possibly asking for a refund on the extended warranty -- time will tell. Either way, I have a background in computer engineering and computer science, so I should be able to understand a thing or two about this car stuff. :D Besides, work has only been stressful to the point of depression.
#13
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Smokey Point, WA
Posts: 186
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My 8 is in the University Mazda right now for the lack of a 6th gear, they are pulling the tranny now, the guys are so far very nice and knowledgable... I felt good handing over my keys, unlike some other dealers... you know the feeling =)
#15
Administrator
Originally Posted by ~)(
Interestingly enough, they still don't know squat about recalls for my car. So how is it that I'm more informed when it's clearly their job to do so?
was the person you talked to a Mazda Master Tech? Was he the Mazda Service Manager?if not thats why he doesnt know. the dealership is a mixed dealership yes? so they have a lot of cars to worry about from different automakers. You only have one to think about. You are eager to find more info They only look for theinfo whenthey need it. Find a standalone deaslership. If you stay there find out who is in charge of the Mazda service and only talk to themfrom then on
the sound syou are hearing are quite normal- the sdais operation is more noticable under full load to some people as the changes are more abrupt. the idle noise is also normal. the car does some things when it drops to idle that change the way its operating for emissions and economy.
#16
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Vashon Island
Posts: 33
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Another vote for the knowledge of the service department at University Mazda. They have done good work on my Miata for the past five years, and recently solved a mysterious glitch in our Mazda3. When I bought my RX-8, I had a good conversation with Paul, their rotary expert, about the Renesis and the 8 in general. He has been working on rotaries since the '70s and made me feel better about the car as well as Mazda's commitment to make it work properly. Drop by and see if they have some suggestions or can look at your car.
#17
05 Champ Car Test Driver
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Calgary, AB - Canada
Posts: 385
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My car sounds the same. But i have a turbo. When i go around 6K it sounds that rattle, like if an empty coke of can was crushing inside the engine. It is like a flap flap flap, metallic sound. I think it is pinging and I can hear it better when driving next to something (highway divider or another car). Never had that while stock.
#20
Administrator
I dont know for certain since i havent actually listened to the cars in question. but from my experience on thisboard and wiht this car it sounds to me like the starter of this thread is hearing normal operation of this car not pinging. you on the other hand sound like you actually have pinging/knock.
#21
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Louisiana
Posts: 127
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by ~)(
I drive an '05 MT/GT model with a little over 3K miles on it, and I'm experiencing weird noises at certain RPMs. The noise it makes is noticeable at WOT; it sounds like some sort of metallic vibration. The sound occurs between the following RPM ranges: 6000 and 6250; 7000-7500; and 8000+. I can sometimes it between 3000-4000, but it's very subtle. I started hearing the sound sometime after the break-in period. (The car has had its 1st oil change at 1500 mi.)
I took the car to my dealer for servicing and performed a test drive with one of the mechanics. The mechanic couldn't hear it at first, but later he confirmed the noise (at 6000-6250 rpm) -- I did the driving. Anyhow, when I picked up the car, they didn't fix a thing; they gave me a piece of paper saying that its a "standard sound" for that engine and the cause of it is pinging. (It basically says that lower octane gasoline may cause higher pinging, and they recommend using only 91 octane or higher.)
Since I bought the car, (I'm the first owner) I have ONLY fed my car 92 octane gas from Chevron -- it doesn't get much better than that. Personally, I find their diagnosis to be a load of crap. If it really is pinging, how come I can reproduce the sound EVERYTIME single time? I'm taking the car back in on Thursday to have them check this 'noise' problem again, but I would like to point out a few possibilities to them. (I've installed the REVi intake and ram air since the last visit to the dealer, and I can still repro the sound. I hope they don't point at the intake and say: "Well, I see you've been f***ing around with your car ... that's the problem! Screw you! ... void warranty ... have a nice day!"
I would like to also add that when the car is idle, it also makes a weird noise (kinda like pistons moving -- but wtf?). This only happens when the engine is very warm.
Have any of you had this problem or can someone provide some insight as to where the problem may be? Thanks.
I took the car to my dealer for servicing and performed a test drive with one of the mechanics. The mechanic couldn't hear it at first, but later he confirmed the noise (at 6000-6250 rpm) -- I did the driving. Anyhow, when I picked up the car, they didn't fix a thing; they gave me a piece of paper saying that its a "standard sound" for that engine and the cause of it is pinging. (It basically says that lower octane gasoline may cause higher pinging, and they recommend using only 91 octane or higher.)
Since I bought the car, (I'm the first owner) I have ONLY fed my car 92 octane gas from Chevron -- it doesn't get much better than that. Personally, I find their diagnosis to be a load of crap. If it really is pinging, how come I can reproduce the sound EVERYTIME single time? I'm taking the car back in on Thursday to have them check this 'noise' problem again, but I would like to point out a few possibilities to them. (I've installed the REVi intake and ram air since the last visit to the dealer, and I can still repro the sound. I hope they don't point at the intake and say: "Well, I see you've been f***ing around with your car ... that's the problem! Screw you! ... void warranty ... have a nice day!"
I would like to also add that when the car is idle, it also makes a weird noise (kinda like pistons moving -- but wtf?). This only happens when the engine is very warm.
Have any of you had this problem or can someone provide some insight as to where the problem may be? Thanks.
I have the exact same thing - to the "t"!!!!!! I've always used 91+ Octane - I've just about given up worrying about it. Its a lease - I'll just hand it back when Im done :D
#22
Bigus Rotus
iTrader: (3)
You need to interview your techs for their credentials. Only have a Mazda Master Tech work on your car. Demand it and nothing else. I searched and found that my tech is very knowledgeable about the rotary. He has been working on them for decades. I also sourced out a former Atkins Rotary engine builder who I bounce things off of and use for small jobs.
You car does not sound like it is pinging - it's the intake working as it should. It's a very complicated setup. WOT on this PCM is pig rich - thus no way to ping your car.
You car does not sound like it is pinging - it's the intake working as it should. It's a very complicated setup. WOT on this PCM is pig rich - thus no way to ping your car.
#23
Administrator
Originally Posted by silver1.3
I have the exact same thing - to the "t"!!!!!! I've always used 91+ Octane - I've just about given up worrying about it. Its a lease - I'll just hand it back when Im done :D
every rx-8 makes certain "weird" noises at certain rpms that are due to the car operating PROPERLY.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Audio Concepts ATL
New Member Forum
21
09-26-2021 01:59 PM
Sifu
RX-8 Parts For Sale/Wanted
3
08-30-2015 10:51 PM
dbarber
Series I Trouble Shooting
14
07-25-2015 01:34 PM