Rear End Sagging- New Springs or Strut or Entire Assembly??
#1
Rear End Sagging- New Springs or Strut or Entire Assembly??
I've noticed my rear end has been sagging significantly lower then my front end ( 2 inches lower in fact - measured from middle of hub to edge of fender) . There is no problem handling or bottoming out or any other significant problem in ride comfort etc, but it does look weird and I am concerned this is NOT healthy for car. I want it set to stock height (15" front and back) and do NOT want to install aftermarket coil overs. I had Bilstein PSS9s on it and it was a nightmare so went back to stock setup. I read and read and read and searched the forums but cannot seem to get a definitive answer to the question: I want to raise the rear ride height to match the front ride height so do I install just Coil Springs, Just the Struts, or an entire Assembly ( Both spring and strut) BTW my front end rides at 15 inches from center of wheel hub to fender edge, my rears are at 13! This can't be right, right? Any help or insight would be greatly appreciated before I bring it in to dealer and spend more than I have to.
#2
If you're going to take it all apart, I would do the springs,shocks and bumpstops at the same time, since we can't diagnose them individually. Do you see any leaks on the shocks? That would be my first guess, but that rear suspension is not fun to work on, I'd just do it all at the same time.
The following users liked this post:
JR RX8 (05-18-2019)
#3
My new 07 GT had numbers all over the place around car: 14.25, 14, 13.75, and 13.5.
Finally after about 10 years, and bottoming out, I put on Bilstein B12 kit which I got from AJUSA for $720.
I comes with the B8 shock and Eibach springs. Now it's 14.25 all around, just where I wanted it.
It's firm, but does the trick for control.
Finally after about 10 years, and bottoming out, I put on Bilstein B12 kit which I got from AJUSA for $720.
I comes with the B8 shock and Eibach springs. Now it's 14.25 all around, just where I wanted it.
It's firm, but does the trick for control.
#5
I was thinking the same thing and I'm glad you confirmed my thoughts. As far as me working on them, that's what I pay my dealer for! LOL My Mech there is an 8 specialist and has been doing my ride for over13 years so I'd rather pay the extra money since i also live in the city and no place to do the work anyway. Thanks again for the advice. I'll let you know who it worked out. cheers!
#6
Brought it in this week. My mech looked at it up on the lift, no leakage and said the car was otherwise fit to drive. I do not like the difference in ride height between front and back (2inches) so am taking your advice and going with the new OE replacement struts and springs right and left and hoping that raises it back up to where the front is. At the very least I will have the knowledge I am driving on solid suspension especially here in NYC with all of its potholes and such! And any rise I get in height will look better than what I have now. Thanks again for the advice.
Cheers!
Cheers!
#7
Job Done ( almost....)
If you're going to take it all apart, I would do the springs,shocks and bumpstops at the same time, since we can't diagnose them individually. Do you see any leaks on the shocks? That would be my first guess, but that rear suspension is not fun to work on, I'd just do it all at the same time.
HOWEVER, it seems that even though it was properly aligned after the work was done ( bearing in mind that the front end on both sides was equal height before the install ) I drove it and noticed the right side "seemed" to be lower. I got out and looked at it from the front and it seemed that way as well. The right side "seemed" lower. So I took it directly back to the dealer and had them measure the ride height on all four corners with a tape and the right front was actually about 1/2 " HIGHER than the left ( remember it seemed lower , but was actually higher by 1/2"! ). So it's back to the dealer to have it looked at again, and see why the front is now off a bit. So now with a new engine ( last year) a new tranny ( last month ) and new suspension in the back Im pretty much driving a new car. ( freaking New York City streets destroy the suspension of a car like this! ) . Can't wait to get it dialed in and then it's off to the mountains for some canyon carving.
Thanks again for the advice.
#9
Registered Lunatic
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 3,581
Likes: 38
From: SF Bay Area, California
I'm in the same boat like OP, rear rides lower than the front, and it has been like that for a while. However, in my case there is also the problem that the car is slanted to the left - the left rear end rides 3/4 inch lower than the right (passenger) side. It's pretty obvious on this photo:
I would obviously like to fix this - if possible, both the slant and the unequal ride from front to back. Are the shocks the likely worst problem, or should I also suspect the springs? I'm also looking for a stock-like setup, nothing was modified in the suspension and want to keep the cost at a reasonable level. The car has 126K miles.
Suggestions for best replacement parts are also welcome.
Thanks!
I would obviously like to fix this - if possible, both the slant and the unequal ride from front to back. Are the shocks the likely worst problem, or should I also suspect the springs? I'm also looking for a stock-like setup, nothing was modified in the suspension and want to keep the cost at a reasonable level. The car has 126K miles.
Suggestions for best replacement parts are also welcome.
Thanks!
#10
I'm in the same boat like OP, rear rides lower than the front, and it has been like that for a while. However, in my case there is also the problem that the car is slanted to the left - the left rear end rides 3/4 inch lower than the right (passenger) side. It's pretty obvious on this photo:
I would obviously like to fix this - if possible, both the slant and the unequal ride from front to back. Are the shocks the likely worst problem, or should I also suspect the springs? I'm also looking for a stock-like setup, nothing was modified in the suspension and want to keep the cost at a reasonable level. The car has 126K miles.
Suggestions for best replacement parts are also welcome.
Thanks!
I would obviously like to fix this - if possible, both the slant and the unequal ride from front to back. Are the shocks the likely worst problem, or should I also suspect the springs? I'm also looking for a stock-like setup, nothing was modified in the suspension and want to keep the cost at a reasonable level. The car has 126K miles.
Suggestions for best replacement parts are also welcome.
Thanks!
The following users liked this post:
bluetii (10-16-2019)
#11
Took it back and had him do a readjustment all around and the car is now sorted,: job done. Looks great, rides great and handles like new. Thanks for the advice man. Nothing like falling back in love with your car. Cheers.
#12
Took it back and had him do a readjustment all around and the car is now sorted,: job done. Looks great, rides great and handles like new. Thanks for the advice man. Nothing like falling back in love with your car. Cheers.
#13
Registered Lunatic
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 3,581
Likes: 38
From: SF Bay Area, California
OK, so the problem is probably with the rear springs then... will have to see if I can get new OEM rear springs for a sane price. Spring kits come with all four and I don't seem to have a problem in the front, so wouldn't want to redo those unless I have to.
As for struts, I have seen KYB Gas-a-Just Monotube rear struts for $80 each... I wonder if they are good replacements or I should look for something else.
As for struts, I have seen KYB Gas-a-Just Monotube rear struts for $80 each... I wonder if they are good replacements or I should look for something else.
#14
It's probably the shocks actually. 2 original Mazda rear shocks should not be expensive. Monotune replacements can be fine, but can also sit lower. Like mentioned above, if you're going to do the work, you may as well get new springs.
Do the shocks have leak marks on them? That would be one indication...
Do the shocks have leak marks on them? That would be one indication...
#15
Registered Lunatic
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 3,581
Likes: 38
From: SF Bay Area, California
I don't see any sign of leak on the shocks.
My first uneducated guess were also the springs since it seems logical that if they get weaker, ride height would be affected. How would it be possible to tell whether the shocks or the springs are the culprit?
Is it normal for the springs to sag at 127K miles?
Loki, you say it's probably the shocks, not the springs. Is this the more common problem for the ride height discrepancy and leaning?
As for the shocks, these are the ones I was eyeing, not sure if they are good stock-like replacement: https://www.carid.com/2004-mazda-rx-...-17817106.html
Especially if I'd leave the stock suspension alone in the front.
In case of springs, what I saw so far were all lowering spring kits (which I don't want), except for these Lesjöfors: https://www.carid.com/lesjofors/rear...79&url=4398050
These are available at other sites too.
Never heard of them and this page also mentions "for normal suspension", whatever that means. My car is a 2004 Sport trim, so I guess the "sport" suspension (like all 6-speed manual cars AFAIK), so I'm uncertain whether these springs would be OK. Does anyone have experience with them?
Was there a difference in springs between the various trims?
My first uneducated guess were also the springs since it seems logical that if they get weaker, ride height would be affected. How would it be possible to tell whether the shocks or the springs are the culprit?
Is it normal for the springs to sag at 127K miles?
Loki, you say it's probably the shocks, not the springs. Is this the more common problem for the ride height discrepancy and leaning?
As for the shocks, these are the ones I was eyeing, not sure if they are good stock-like replacement: https://www.carid.com/2004-mazda-rx-...-17817106.html
Especially if I'd leave the stock suspension alone in the front.
In case of springs, what I saw so far were all lowering spring kits (which I don't want), except for these Lesjöfors: https://www.carid.com/lesjofors/rear...79&url=4398050
These are available at other sites too.
Never heard of them and this page also mentions "for normal suspension", whatever that means. My car is a 2004 Sport trim, so I guess the "sport" suspension (like all 6-speed manual cars AFAIK), so I'm uncertain whether these springs would be OK. Does anyone have experience with them?
Was there a difference in springs between the various trims?
#16
You can do a simple shock test, just press down heavily (hard as you can) on each corner of the car and see if it rebounds smoothly or if it wobbles before settling. Wobbles: bad shock on that corner.
It's not true on all cars, but on this one the static pressure in the shock plays into ride height. Some aftermarket shocks result in lower ride height because they don't account for this. As far I know all OEM replacement shocks don't have that problem, only the performance stuff.
It could also be the springs but unless something drastic has happened and one spring snapped, but that wouldn't be my first guess. You can certainly try to replace both springs, shocks and bumpstops with OEM stuff while you're in there, it will fix the problem, but if budget is a concern then I'd try to confirm the shock diagnosis.
Working on the rear suspension without a lift suuuucks, I'd bring it somewhere to get done, so they might have their own opinions.
It's not true on all cars, but on this one the static pressure in the shock plays into ride height. Some aftermarket shocks result in lower ride height because they don't account for this. As far I know all OEM replacement shocks don't have that problem, only the performance stuff.
It could also be the springs but unless something drastic has happened and one spring snapped, but that wouldn't be my first guess. You can certainly try to replace both springs, shocks and bumpstops with OEM stuff while you're in there, it will fix the problem, but if budget is a concern then I'd try to confirm the shock diagnosis.
Working on the rear suspension without a lift suuuucks, I'd bring it somewhere to get done, so they might have their own opinions.
#17
Registered Lunatic
iTrader: (1)
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 3,581
Likes: 38
From: SF Bay Area, California
So as it turns out, replacing the shocks indeed cured the tilted rear issue, and the car is level now. It is also not sagging anymore in the rear, although there is still some rearwards rake, but it's really not too noticeable. Certainly way less than before.
I got all four shocks, strut bellows and bump stops replaced.
I went with the KYB Gas-a-Just shocks, since I found a good deal on them (the rears were on clearance for only 36 bucks apiece brand new, fronts were 78). Ride is great on them, so I'm happy. Doesn't seem to be all that different from the stock ride, actually. OEM shocks would have been a lot more expensive, as usual.
I also bought new OEM springs, based on part number FE02-28-011 which is supposed to be the one for a 2004-2008 RX-8 with sport suspension (like mine), but interestingly, they were a little shorter and skinnier than the ones in the car:
So I returned them and the factory springs were put back in. There wasn't anything visibly wrong with them anyway. The only difference is that they were swapped from left to right and vice versa.
I got all four shocks, strut bellows and bump stops replaced.
I went with the KYB Gas-a-Just shocks, since I found a good deal on them (the rears were on clearance for only 36 bucks apiece brand new, fronts were 78). Ride is great on them, so I'm happy. Doesn't seem to be all that different from the stock ride, actually. OEM shocks would have been a lot more expensive, as usual.
I also bought new OEM springs, based on part number FE02-28-011 which is supposed to be the one for a 2004-2008 RX-8 with sport suspension (like mine), but interestingly, they were a little shorter and skinnier than the ones in the car:
So I returned them and the factory springs were put back in. There wasn't anything visibly wrong with them anyway. The only difference is that they were swapped from left to right and vice versa.
Last edited by Tamas; 10-05-2019 at 05:14 PM.
#19
Hi Tamas, would you mind telling me where you bought the OEM springs that you eventually returned ?
That part number FE02-28-011, is all i can find. I dont want to order them and find, as you did, that they are shorter and, at least appearance wise, weaker !
Thanks !
That part number FE02-28-011, is all i can find. I dont want to order them and find, as you did, that they are shorter and, at least appearance wise, weaker !
Thanks !
#23
OK, so the problem is probably with the rear springs then... will have to see if I can get new OEM rear springs for a sane price. Spring kits come with all four and I don't seem to have a problem in the front, so wouldn't want to redo those unless I have to.
As for struts, I have seen KYB Gas-a-Just Monotube rear struts for $80 each... I wonder if they are good replacements or I should look for something else.
As for struts, I have seen KYB Gas-a-Just Monotube rear struts for $80 each... I wonder if they are good replacements or I should look for something else.
#24
Strut Assembly
I have a question about which struts to use. I had recently replaced my rotors and it turned out that I got the wrong ones because they were for the base model and I had the sport so I had to run and get the right ones. I was wondering if there is a difference between the base model suspension and the sport model. The strut assembly that I'm getting is Monroe, 171123L&171123R
#25
I went ahead and ordered these rear springs from BAM wholesale. Part # FE02-28-011. Advertised as a genuine oem replacement part, they are indeed 1/2" shorter when measured standing on a work bench. I stopped when i realized i dont even need to use spring compressors to assemble them.
As Team suggests, I suppose the compression rate could be higher to offset the initial height difference, but Im concerned the car will sit lower.
Anyone actually used these supposedly oem springs?
As Team suggests, I suppose the compression rate could be higher to offset the initial height difference, but Im concerned the car will sit lower.
Anyone actually used these supposedly oem springs?
Last edited by Kiwiaudio; 05-27-2021 at 05:07 PM.