rough idle and misfire after a track day
#1
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
rough idle and misfire after a track day
Hi,
Yesterday I was on a track day driving my RX8 really hard. I was going like crazy on the corners, so there was a lot of pressure on my car. Constantly revving between 6-8k.
Suddenly my car engine shut off. After I stopped I could not power it on. The temperature pointer arrow at that time was in the middle, so it was not overheated.
After 10-15 minutes I tried starting my car again and it was misfiring and running very rough.
My car had 50000km (31000 miles) service a week ago. Car is all stock. Today I went to a Mazda dealer and asked them to change spark plugs.
The dealer who I don't trust very much told me even after replacing spark plugs the misfiring is still there and they have to do a compression test,
With the new spark plugs idle is much better but there is still running rough, but there is no misfire. I can't explain why but I do not trust the dealer.
I got the car back in for a compression test and they did one and showed me a print out showing graphs of low compression in front rotor bank. I couldn't tell if the print out was from my car or another car from another time. There was not time or date on it so it could be anything.
I asked him have he checked what is the cause of the CEL on. He said the error code was saying there is low compression. This sounded complete BS to me.
He said I will have to have the engine rebuilt which will cost me about $5000. I want to point out that I don't trust their word and think it is something much easier to fix while they charge me for much more.
How could the misfire have gone away with the new plugs but there is still some rough idle. Any advice? Have they done something fishy?
Yesterday I was on a track day driving my RX8 really hard. I was going like crazy on the corners, so there was a lot of pressure on my car. Constantly revving between 6-8k.
Suddenly my car engine shut off. After I stopped I could not power it on. The temperature pointer arrow at that time was in the middle, so it was not overheated.
After 10-15 minutes I tried starting my car again and it was misfiring and running very rough.
My car had 50000km (31000 miles) service a week ago. Car is all stock. Today I went to a Mazda dealer and asked them to change spark plugs.
The dealer who I don't trust very much told me even after replacing spark plugs the misfiring is still there and they have to do a compression test,
With the new spark plugs idle is much better but there is still running rough, but there is no misfire. I can't explain why but I do not trust the dealer.
I got the car back in for a compression test and they did one and showed me a print out showing graphs of low compression in front rotor bank. I couldn't tell if the print out was from my car or another car from another time. There was not time or date on it so it could be anything.
I asked him have he checked what is the cause of the CEL on. He said the error code was saying there is low compression. This sounded complete BS to me.
He said I will have to have the engine rebuilt which will cost me about $5000. I want to point out that I don't trust their word and think it is something much easier to fix while they charge me for much more.
How could the misfire have gone away with the new plugs but there is still some rough idle. Any advice? Have they done something fishy?
Last edited by voe; 09-03-2012 at 02:17 AM.
#2
Registered
If you have an s2 then your car is 2009+ and should still be under the 5 year 60k miles powertrain warranty which is free replacement of the engine. Not only that but you should even still be under the 3 year/ 36k mile bumper to bumper warranty. Why would they be trying to charge you 5k while you are still under warranty?
#4
BECAUSE RACECAR
iTrader: (10)
If the car just shut off while you were on the track it very well could be a catastrophic failure of a seal on the front rotor. Something that's cheaper than replacing the engine though is replacing the ignition coils and plug wires but if the dealer did the compression test correctly your motor might be shot. I've only seen one naturally aspirated Series 1 RX-8 around here have a massive failure (apex seal shattered) so I don't think it's very common...
#6
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Will try and check the rest of your recommendations.
Thanks.
#8
Registered
Mazda will be trying to give you a remanufactured engine which even at 5k you could be looking at replacing it within 20k miles again or less. Some remans last quite a long time and others do not. If you go with a independent rotary shop they could build you a quality engine out of good parts and make sure it lasts much longer than the reman.
#9
Super Moderator
PM Sent to OP
#10
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This morning decided to start with checking the MAF sensor when I noticed that one of the pipes to the air duct is missing:
![](http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8452/7925363296_6683cfc2eb_z.jpg)
Not sure how it happened but it could either have fallen while driving or it was removed by the dealer. I searched but could not locate the disconnected pipe.
BTW, the MAF sensor (two wires) looks clean, the bulb has very smal residue on one side and clean on the other. So I reckon fault is not with the MAF sensor.
![](http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8452/7925363296_6683cfc2eb_z.jpg)
Not sure how it happened but it could either have fallen while driving or it was removed by the dealer. I searched but could not locate the disconnected pipe.
BTW, the MAF sensor (two wires) looks clean, the bulb has very smal residue on one side and clean on the other. So I reckon fault is not with the MAF sensor.
#12
Super Moderator
Hi and thanks for the info..
I am pretty sure this is hole in accordion is blank, not used, (I cant check my car right now).
Now you have one of the very early S2's, not that there is any changes of concern.
So, you are still having rough idling?
I would not necessarily discount what the dealer told you, although there is NO CEL Code for "low compressions"...does not exist...misfire..yes.
I see no reason for them to tell you something that is not correct...if you have low compressions on front rotor then sadly only a rebuild/new engine will rectify.
Are you the original owner?
I would be contacting Mazda Australia and just try and see 'if' they are prepared to offer any assistance (re-new engine) IF, you are repaired to pay something to-wards it.
I would also be getting a second opinion from another Rotary Expert, or Dealer in the east.
Does not look good.
I am pretty sure this is hole in accordion is blank, not used, (I cant check my car right now).
Now you have one of the very early S2's, not that there is any changes of concern.
So, you are still having rough idling?
I would not necessarily discount what the dealer told you, although there is NO CEL Code for "low compressions"...does not exist...misfire..yes.
I see no reason for them to tell you something that is not correct...if you have low compressions on front rotor then sadly only a rebuild/new engine will rectify.
Are you the original owner?
I would be contacting Mazda Australia and just try and see 'if' they are prepared to offer any assistance (re-new engine) IF, you are repaired to pay something to-wards it.
I would also be getting a second opinion from another Rotary Expert, or Dealer in the east.
Does not look good.
#13
Registered
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I wonder if the CEL is on wouldn't it point that there is also another issue apart from the potential loss of compression?
I want to note that after replacing the spark plugs car runs without misfiring, but there is still rough some rough idle remaining.
I mean if the issue was only broken apex seal why would I also get CEL on at the time of driving the car when it suddenly shut off by itself.
Would that be caused by loss of compression, or could there be something else causing the engine to shut down and cause the CEL to come on?
Just thinking out loud. Any suggestions are welcomed.
I want to note that after replacing the spark plugs car runs without misfiring, but there is still rough some rough idle remaining.
I mean if the issue was only broken apex seal why would I also get CEL on at the time of driving the car when it suddenly shut off by itself.
Would that be caused by loss of compression, or could there be something else causing the engine to shut down and cause the CEL to come on?
Just thinking out loud. Any suggestions are welcomed.
#15
Registered
My car has not ever had that hose there, I went and double checked before I said it should be empty. Did you go out and check it with a flashlight yet? You should see a plug in it.
If I had to guess I would say that the 04-08 and 09-11 rx8's share that intake tube, and that hole was used on the 04-08 ones(what that shop manual would be for) and not used on the newer ones. I looked around for pictures of series 1 rx8 engine bays and there is a hose plugged into that part for them.
If I had to guess I would say that the 04-08 and 09-11 rx8's share that intake tube, and that hole was used on the 04-08 ones(what that shop manual would be for) and not used on the newer ones. I looked around for pictures of series 1 rx8 engine bays and there is a hose plugged into that part for them.
#16
rev it up
Check out these guys if you need a rotary mechanic. The owners in Melbourne seem to rate them highly RX8 Club Australia • View topic - RX-8 Specialties workshop relocation
#17
Super Moderator
If I had to guess I would say that the 04-08 and 09-11 rx8's share that intake tube, and that hole was used on the 04-08 ones(what that shop manual would be for) and not used on the newer ones. I looked around for pictures of series 1 rx8 engine bays and there is a hose plugged into that part for them.
3 (S1) to 2 (S2), although the hole and nipple platform are there the hole does not go into/through to the air pipe like S1.
![Smilie](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#18
Registered
I know it does not go through, it is just plugged. Why would they even have that part there if it wasnt the s1 part with a plugged hole? If they were going to make a whole different part wouldn't it be cleaner to just not have that piece on there?
#19
Super Moderator
Found a INTAKE-AIR SYSTEM HOSE ROUTING DIAGRAM here (M A Z D A)
![](http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8302/7926677658_bba728b40b_o.png)
The green arrows point to the missing pipe.
![](http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8302/7926677658_bba728b40b_o.png)
The green arrows point to the missing pipe.
Much of the external stuff is not the same for your S2 as shown in that Mazda Manual you are looking at...which is ALL for Series 1.
#20
Super Moderator
Lets not confuse the issue about vac lines..![Smilie](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/smile.gif)
Nothing unusual for a car market to use the same "moulding" for a car part, they just don't pierce the hole as it is not required in ALL S2's in this case as it has one less vac line.
VOE...
Are you still getting a yellow CEL light on dash?
As I said before there is no CEL or DTC (symptom code) for 'Loss of compression' as there is not a fixed sensor to measure "loss of compression"...
From factory there is only one real way to measure and that is with a proper Comp Tester ( if you are coming to Adelaide I can do it for you as I have a Mazda RE factory Comp Tester.
As said before you possibly have a fractured Apex Seal or damaged Corner Seal, this is how you 'generally' get weak compressions..
Did you get a copy of the readings?, if so post them here...it could tell us a lot.
As I see it in your case we can talk until the cows come home, you need to get a second opinion from someone who can physically re-check compressions and some other parts.
![Smilie](https://www.rx8club.com/images/smilies/smile.gif)
Nothing unusual for a car market to use the same "moulding" for a car part, they just don't pierce the hole as it is not required in ALL S2's in this case as it has one less vac line.
VOE...
Are you still getting a yellow CEL light on dash?
As I said before there is no CEL or DTC (symptom code) for 'Loss of compression' as there is not a fixed sensor to measure "loss of compression"...
From factory there is only one real way to measure and that is with a proper Comp Tester ( if you are coming to Adelaide I can do it for you as I have a Mazda RE factory Comp Tester.
As said before you possibly have a fractured Apex Seal or damaged Corner Seal, this is how you 'generally' get weak compressions..
Did you get a copy of the readings?, if so post them here...it could tell us a lot.
As I see it in your case we can talk until the cows come home, you need to get a second opinion from someone who can physically re-check compressions and some other parts.
#21
Rockie Mountain Newbie
#22
Registered
BC looking at the pictures he posted it is definitely a series 2 if he took that picture. He also has another post asking if there are any plans for the cobb accessport for series 2 so he pretty definitively has a series 2.
I think this is the first series 2 I have seen with a blown engine if the dealer is right. Anyone else seen another one?
I think this is the first series 2 I have seen with a blown engine if the dealer is right. Anyone else seen another one?
Last edited by xexok; 09-04-2012 at 01:22 PM.
#24
Registered
Fwiw there was a poster around here about a year ago (Texas RX8 R3 I think was his name) who had similar problems after a track day. If I remember correctly his car kept going into limp mode but didn't actually die though. I believe it turned out to be a clogged/failed cat. I can't find his thread, it may have been deleted for some reason.