Nav, should I bother?
#1
Nav, should I bother?
As we know, the Shinka, strangely, doesn't offer a factory Nav system. However, my dealer offers a (supposedly superior to OEM) aftermarket unit for $2k installed. I presume it retracts, but need to verify.
Standalone units are 1/4 of the price, but not as large display and of course stand abruptly on the dash. It would be transportable to my other vehicles/afoot tho'. And for the price I could upgrade as technology advances.
Still, the retracting unit calls to my engineering elegance side.
Would welcome insight from those that have gone down the Shinka-Nav road. TIA
Standalone units are 1/4 of the price, but not as large display and of course stand abruptly on the dash. It would be transportable to my other vehicles/afoot tho'. And for the price I could upgrade as technology advances.
Still, the retracting unit calls to my engineering elegance side.
Would welcome insight from those that have gone down the Shinka-Nav road. TIA
#2
Guest
Posts: n/a
My OEM NAV just happened to be installed in a deeply discounted brand new 2004 RX-8 when I was shopping in September 2005. I can't say the OEM NAV is worth $2,000, but my car was discounted over $8,000 off sticker so I considered the OEM NAV free and it's certainly worth more than that.
I agree the elegance of a built-in unit is great, but not at that price (unless money's no object). If you're in a metro area the portable NAV is also a target for smash-and-grab so the OEM NAV has an advantage there too, but if you're buying a $400 portable unit you can afford to have it stolen a few times before you reach the cost of the OEM NAV.
I agree the elegance of a built-in unit is great, but not at that price (unless money's no object). If you're in a metro area the portable NAV is also a target for smash-and-grab so the OEM NAV has an advantage there too, but if you're buying a $400 portable unit you can afford to have it stolen a few times before you reach the cost of the OEM NAV.
#3
'05 Titanium 6sp
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: St. Paul, MN
Posts: 368
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I would definately have to see the supposed "superior to OEM" unit before id pay 2g for it. Everyone ive come across says the factory nav is great. It would definatley have to have the sleek looks of the factory nav unit. Id never want the stand alone unit just because it wouldnt fit seemlessly with the interior like the factory setup does. but thats just me. Some people like the idea that they could pull it out and use it for hiking and what not.
#4
The oem nav is easily one of the worse navi units i've used. I say this mostly due to 1) zoom times are not snappy, 2) graphics are cheesy and sparse. 3) it's priced at least double what it should be. 4) It is difficult to locate things when entering an address/location.
On the other hand, the navi does work fine if you need to know where you are, or know the general area of where you want to go - point to the location, click "select destination" and you're set. Being built into the car has it's advantages, and it does have dead reckoning which your aftermarkets one will lack.
My car has the OEM navi, I like it, I use it every day, but I'm under no illusion that it's the best thing since sliced bread.
On the other hand, the navi does work fine if you need to know where you are, or know the general area of where you want to go - point to the location, click "select destination" and you're set. Being built into the car has it's advantages, and it does have dead reckoning which your aftermarkets one will lack.
My car has the OEM navi, I like it, I use it every day, but I'm under no illusion that it's the best thing since sliced bread.
#5
Shink'd Out for 2006
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Morris Plains, NJ
Posts: 503
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think the Sirius unit is what causes the Nav to not fit in the console. The Sirius unit would have to be relocated and major dash and armrest work. I don't think a factory unit is possible post sale.
In terms of aftermarket, you could do a Pioneer/Eclipse/Kenwood DVD that sits under passenger floor mat. Adn push out to a nice 7 or 6 inch touch screen mounted on ur dash. Smaller would prolly better though. I hate those magellan stick on units so dont go that route.
Time
In terms of aftermarket, you could do a Pioneer/Eclipse/Kenwood DVD that sits under passenger floor mat. Adn push out to a nice 7 or 6 inch touch screen mounted on ur dash. Smaller would prolly better though. I hate those magellan stick on units so dont go that route.
Time
#6
Ahead of its time
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: GA
Posts: 1,508
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by time4akshun
I think the Sirius unit is what causes the Nav to not fit in the console. The Sirius unit would have to be relocated and major dash and armrest work. I don't think a factory unit is possible post sale.
..
..
Since I liked the NAV it was the reason I shied away from purchasing a Shinka Edition. Dont know what Mazda was thinking.
#7
Shink'd Out for 2006
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Morris Plains, NJ
Posts: 503
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
u had Sirius installed aftermarket. The factory units r done in dash thus killing the space for nav placement and wiring. You probably made the right decision to get both.
Is your Sirius controlled by the factory radio controls?
Time
Is your Sirius controlled by the factory radio controls?
Time
#9
Ahead of its time
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: GA
Posts: 1,508
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by time4akshun
u had Sirius installed aftermarket. The factory units r done in dash thus killing the space for nav placement and wiring. You probably made the right decision to get both.
Is your Sirius controlled by the factory radio controls?
Time
Is your Sirius controlled by the factory radio controls?
Time
Yes, Sirius is controlled by radio controls as well as steering wheel controls.
#10
Mr. T is my copilot
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: los angeles
Posts: 794
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by mysql101
My car has the OEM navi, I like it, I use it every day, but I'm under no illusion that it's the best thing since sliced bread.
#11
I researched on this problem for a long while and I decided to get an ASUS A636 PDA/GPS. Compare to getting all the parts for an OEM NAV, an decent after martket NAV, or a CarPC, the PDA is by far the most useful and being cheaper. I am out of the country right now, but I will try to write a review for the unit in use with a Rx8.
p.s. get the A636N if you are in Europe or Aus.
p.s. get the A636N if you are in Europe or Aus.
#13
Registered
I haven't noticed all the negatives you guys are pointing out about the navigation. I have an 06, so maybe that is why? I really like and it was really easy to program for me when I had to go on a road trip to deliver things all over Seattle, where I definitely don't know my way around. It did a great job, didn't get me lost or anything. The only thing I noticed was on all the curving freeway ramps it was a little bit slow telling me which lane I needed to be in, but I had already determined that due to the giant freeway sign that pointed to I-5 south on the way home. The reason it was slow was because I was going quite a bit faster than the actual posted speed on the ramp. It said something like 15-20 MPH and I was going somewhere around 35-40, so it was slightly slow. It beeped and told me where to go about a second too late.
I think it is updated quite well, too. It can even find my house out in the country, which I have yet to find a navigation unit otherwise that can. My stepdad's Lincoln Blackwood couldn't find anything within about a 10 mile radius of my house. In some directions it was actually quite a bit more that it couldn't find. I have several friends with portable units that can do a GPS location but can't find roads or anything in the area because their maps obviously are outdated or something, although we have lived in the location for over 25 years so, surely the maps ought to have the roads out by me since they aren't new. My navigation also worked in a brand new (about a year old) housing development. It listed the roads and everything.
I must have an "updated" version.
I don't use mine every day but it is really handy when I am not entirely sure exactly where I am going (like first time going to a certain location) so I just enter the address and it tells me how to get there and does a great job.
I love mine and I don't regret ordering it. Besides, when people are admiring my car I push the open button so it pops up and everyone drools more.
I think it is updated quite well, too. It can even find my house out in the country, which I have yet to find a navigation unit otherwise that can. My stepdad's Lincoln Blackwood couldn't find anything within about a 10 mile radius of my house. In some directions it was actually quite a bit more that it couldn't find. I have several friends with portable units that can do a GPS location but can't find roads or anything in the area because their maps obviously are outdated or something, although we have lived in the location for over 25 years so, surely the maps ought to have the roads out by me since they aren't new. My navigation also worked in a brand new (about a year old) housing development. It listed the roads and everything.
I must have an "updated" version.
I don't use mine every day but it is really handy when I am not entirely sure exactly where I am going (like first time going to a certain location) so I just enter the address and it tells me how to get there and does a great job.
I love mine and I don't regret ordering it. Besides, when people are admiring my car I push the open button so it pops up and everyone drools more.
#14
Originally Posted by BunnyGirl
I haven't noticed all the negatives you guys are pointing out about the navigation. I have an 06, so maybe that is why? I really like and it was really easy to program for me when I had to go on a road trip to deliver things all over Seattle, where I definitely don't know my way around. It did a great job, didn't get me lost or anything. The only thing I noticed was on all the curving freeway ramps it was a little bit slow telling me which lane I needed to be in,
I never said it couldn't provide directions, it does that just fine.
#16
i like my nav. only complaint i have is some occassional hiccups (pretty rare, but once it kept on telling me i was facing the wrong direction and going a direction different than where i really was. it corrected itself after like 5 minutes, but still, pretty weird. only happened once.)
but the main complaint i have about the nav system is the fact that i have like a 2001 map cd so they're missing CRAPloads of new streets. And from what I understand, NavTech/Mazda charges 400+ dollars for a new map dvd?
i use my nav pretty often actually. i seriously love the thing.
but the main complaint i have about the nav system is the fact that i have like a 2001 map cd so they're missing CRAPloads of new streets. And from what I understand, NavTech/Mazda charges 400+ dollars for a new map dvd?
i use my nav pretty often actually. i seriously love the thing.
#17
幹他媽!
aftermarket navs are more prone to break-in & theft. so, the trade-off is u pay a bit more up front for the factory nav, but are almost guaranteed that it will never get stolen...
#18
the new maps are $199 from navteq, but they're still from 2004. the older maps are from 2002 so if you're in an area that has had new roads built recently, you'll probably be disappointed with the upgraded maps.
#19
Registered
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 1,223
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Detrich
aftermarket navs are more prone to break-in & theft. so, the trade-off is u pay a bit more up front for the factory nav, but are almost guaranteed that it will never get stolen...
My gps is also my pda and phone. When I leave the car it is in my pocket. I can get over ten years worth of map updates for less than the cost of the oem nav.
Ok, you want coolness? Voice command. Since the pda already has over 3000 of my names and addresses in it, all I have to do is say "look up name" and then "navigate to" and it's ready to go.
Oh, and traffic reports and automatic rerouting. My gps is set to pick up traffic updates every ten minutes and if it finds delays on my route it asks if I want a new route.
Bluetooth too. The 8 doesn't have it, but in other cars like Acura, it will also route the driving prompts and phone calls through the stereo.
The oem is nicely integrated but it is really expensive for what it offers. Mazda does not come close to leading edge when it comes to the electronics. (we don't even have an automatic thermostat or auto-off headlights)
I doubt that I would ever spend $2k or more for oem nav. Maybe some day it will be a couple of hundred bucks.
#20
Shink'd Out for 2006
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Morris Plains, NJ
Posts: 503
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Beach,
You can't possibly talk that highly bout your pda/gps and not mention a brand/model. Give it up!
Time
You can't possibly talk that highly bout your pda/gps and not mention a brand/model. Give it up!
Time
Originally Posted by beachdog
It goes without saying that you should never leave anything small enough to carry visible in your car. Any and all electronics are especially tempting.
My gps is also my pda and phone. When I leave the car it is in my pocket. I can get over ten years worth of map updates for less than the cost of the oem nav.
Ok, you want coolness? Voice command. Since the pda already has over 3000 of my names and addresses in it, all I have to do is say "look up name" and then "navigate to" and it's ready to go.
Oh, and traffic reports and automatic rerouting. My gps is set to pick up traffic updates every ten minutes and if it finds delays on my route it asks if I want a new route.
Bluetooth too. The 8 doesn't have it, but in other cars like Acura, it will also route the driving prompts and phone calls through the stereo.
The oem is nicely integrated but it is really expensive for what it offers. Mazda does not come close to leading edge when it comes to the electronics. (we don't even have an automatic thermostat or auto-off headlights)
I doubt that I would ever spend $2k or more for oem nav. Maybe some day it will be a couple of hundred bucks.
My gps is also my pda and phone. When I leave the car it is in my pocket. I can get over ten years worth of map updates for less than the cost of the oem nav.
Ok, you want coolness? Voice command. Since the pda already has over 3000 of my names and addresses in it, all I have to do is say "look up name" and then "navigate to" and it's ready to go.
Oh, and traffic reports and automatic rerouting. My gps is set to pick up traffic updates every ten minutes and if it finds delays on my route it asks if I want a new route.
Bluetooth too. The 8 doesn't have it, but in other cars like Acura, it will also route the driving prompts and phone calls through the stereo.
The oem is nicely integrated but it is really expensive for what it offers. Mazda does not come close to leading edge when it comes to the electronics. (we don't even have an automatic thermostat or auto-off headlights)
I doubt that I would ever spend $2k or more for oem nav. Maybe some day it will be a couple of hundred bucks.
#21
Registered
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 1,223
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I work for the manufacturer so I don't want to violate the rules. PM sent.
Above I was just trying to illustrate that innovation is not the strong suit of the oem nav. Just like a true stereo junkie is going to yank the factory stuff.
I forgot to mention that I also have 4gb of mp3's on it too.
Above I was just trying to illustrate that innovation is not the strong suit of the oem nav. Just like a true stereo junkie is going to yank the factory stuff.
I forgot to mention that I also have 4gb of mp3's on it too.
#22
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by beachdog
My gps is also my pda and phone. When I leave the car it is in my pocket. I can get over ten years worth of map updates for less than the cost of the oem nav.
Ok, you want coolness? Voice command. Since the pda already has over 3000 of my names and addresses in it, all I have to do is say "look up name" and then "navigate to" and it's ready to go.
Oh, and traffic reports and automatic rerouting. My gps is set to pick up traffic updates every ten minutes and if it finds delays on my route it asks if I want a new route.
Ok, you want coolness? Voice command. Since the pda already has over 3000 of my names and addresses in it, all I have to do is say "look up name" and then "navigate to" and it's ready to go.
Oh, and traffic reports and automatic rerouting. My gps is set to pick up traffic updates every ten minutes and if it finds delays on my route it asks if I want a new route.
#23
I'm Burnin for You
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Bucks County, PA
Posts: 358
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
OEM Nav =
Yes I have my issues with it, my TomTom in my 3 was better. But I'm not gonna bitch cause I got a fully loaded 04 for less then 22k with 17k miles on it when I bought it in March.
Yes I have my issues with it, my TomTom in my 3 was better. But I'm not gonna bitch cause I got a fully loaded 04 for less then 22k with 17k miles on it when I bought it in March.
#25
Resu Deretsiger
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: United Kingdom, for now
Posts: 369
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Check out Consumer Reports; they just did a big comparison on Nav systems.
I've got a Garmin GPSMAP76s. I love it for a handheld, but it lacks as a car-mounted system. Glad I didn't have to pay for it; I would have gone with something more vehicle related.
I've got a Garmin GPSMAP76s. I love it for a handheld, but it lacks as a car-mounted system. Glad I didn't have to pay for it; I would have gone with something more vehicle related.